Knoxville residents may soon see how a new Tennessee law affects their ability to observe police activity in public. The law, enacted by the state legislature last year, creates a 25‑foot “buffer zone” around officers performing official duties and makes it a misdemeanor to refuse to move outside that zone. Violations can result in up to six months in jail.
Media organizations—including the Tennessee Lookout, Nashville Banner, Nexstar Media Group, Scripps Media, Gannett, Nashville Public Media and Tegna—filed a federal lawsuit in July after the law took effect, arguing that it violates the First Amendment and is unconstitutionally vague. They sought an injunction to halt enforcement while the case proceeds.
According to KnoxTNToday, the U.S. District Judge William L. Campbell Jr. denied the request for an injunction, prompting the plaintiffs to appeal. The 6th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals has now struck down Judge Campbell’s decision, stating that he failed to address the “most important” consideration in First Amendment cases: the likelihood that the media will succeed on the merits of their constitutional challenge.
“The district court must create an adequate factual record on these and any other relevant issues for that court or ours to apply the applicable standard for injunctive relief,” the appellate panel wrote.
Attorney Paul McAdoo of the Reporters Committee for Freedom of the Press, serving as lead counsel for the media groups, warned that the law “has grave implications for the ability of reporters and news organizations … to exercise their First Amendment rights.” He argued the statute gives officers “standardless discretion” to keep journalists and the public at a distance, even when no safety risk exists, and provides no exceptions for situations where a 25‑foot gap would impede news gathering.
The law applies to all citizens, not just journalists, and authorizes officers to order anyone to stay back at a parade, rally, arrest scene, accident or any public event. Critics say it could be used to prevent ordinary residents from filming police conduct, a concern that resonates with Knoxville’s community members who rely on video evidence to hold law‑enforcement accountable.
What’s next? The appellate court’s ruling does not automatically halt enforcement of the buffer‑zone law, but it signals that the case will move forward with a more thorough factual record. The plaintiffs are expected to request a new hearing on the injunction, and the outcome could determine whether Knoxville’s streets remain open for public and press documentation of police activity.
Sources: knoxtntoday.com