Warren residents learned Monday that Judge John Chmura, chief judge of the 37th District Court in Warren and Center Line, was acquitted of a “super” drunk‑driving charge but convicted of a lesser operating‑while‑intoxicated (OUI) offense. The verdict came after a four‑hour trial in Novi’s 52‑I District Court, presided over by Judge David Law, who ruled that Chmura’s blood‑alcohol level at the time of the March 25 crash could have been below the 0.17 % threshold required for the more serious charge.
According to the Macomb Daily, the prosecution argued Chmura’s blood‑alcohol was 0.196 % based on a hospital draw taken one hour and 15 minutes after the crash. Defense expert Donald Henson, citing an absorption rate of 0.14 % per hour and a plus‑minus factor of 0.018, suggested the level could have been as low as 0.163 % at the moment Chmura struck a SMART bus in Sterling Heights. The judge emphasized that “beyond reasonable doubt” is a high standard and that the prosecution had not met it for the super‑drunk charge.
Chmura, who has served on the bench for three decades, admitted to Officer John Journeau that he “probably drank too much” and displayed classic signs of intoxication, including slurred speech, difficulty locating his driver’s license paperwork, and failing three eye‑movement tests. The officer noted Chmura appeared “woozy,” though the defense suggested the air‑bag deployment may have contributed to his condition.
Assistant St. Clair County Prosecutor Paul Soderberg called Chmura’s driving “incredibly dangerous,” arguing that the chance Chmura’s blood‑alcohol was below 0.17 % was “so slim it is not reasonable.” Defense attorney David Kramer criticized law‑enforcement for not obtaining video evidence from Da Francesco’s Ristorante and Bar, where Chmura was last seen drinking, and for failing to ask about his last drink.
The crash itself occurred at a relatively low speed on Van Dyke Avenue between 19 Mile and Hall Road (M‑59). While Chmura’s Ford Fusion sustained significant damage and the airbag deployed, the SMART bus suffered only minor damage. No other vehicles were involved, and no injuries were reported.
Sentencing has not yet been set. If convicted of the OUI charge, Chmura faces up to 93 days in jail, a 30‑day driver’s license suspension, six months of a restricted license, and up to 360 hours of community service. A super‑drunk conviction would have carried harsher penalties, including up to six months in jail and a mandatory ignition‑interlock device.
What’s next: The court will schedule a sentencing hearing in the coming weeks. Residents are encouraged to follow updates from the 37th District Court for any changes to Chmura’s license status or community service requirements.
Sources: macombdaily.com, macombdaily.com, macombdaily.com