Marjorie has been on Capitol Hill for over two decades, which in Seattle restaurant terms is roughly equivalent to geological time. What surprises most people is that it has never tried to be anything other than what it is: a small, serious dinner spot run by chef Donna Moodie, who opened it in 2001 and still runs the kitchen with a kind of quiet confidence that the city’s newer wave of buzzier places rarely match.
I went on a Thursday, which I’d recommend over a weekend if you like actually being able to hear your table. The room seats maybe forty people comfortably — exposed brick, warm overhead lighting, the kind of space where the decor doesn’t shout at you. We got there around 6:30 and were seated immediately with a reservation. Without one, you’d probably be waiting at the small bar, which isn’t a bad fate since they pour generously and the bartender knows what she’s doing.
The menu changes regularly, but it has a consistent sensibility: global influences applied with a light hand, seasonal produce from local farms, proteins treated as the main event rather than an afterthought. That night I started with a roasted beet salad that had some kind of citrus-tahini situation going on underneath — not fussy, just well-balanced. My friend had the soup, a coconut-laced squash with herbs I couldn’t fully identify but didn’t want to stop eating.
For mains, I went with the lamb chops. They arrived perfectly cooked, medium-rare without being asked, with a grain pilaf and a bright herb sauce that cut through the richness exactly right. My friend had a fish dish — black cod, I think — that came with roasted vegetables and a miso-adjacent glaze. We both cleaned our plates, which doesn’t happen to me as often as I’d like to admit.
Dessert was a chocolate pot de crème with sea salt and a shortbread on the side. I’d had a version of this elsewhere and it was fine. This one was noticeably better — richer, less sweet, the salt actually integrated rather than decorative. It costs around $10 for desserts, $15–22 for starters, $30–40 for mains. For the quality and the neighborhood, that feels right.
What makes Marjorie stand out in 2024 isn’t that it’s doing something revolutionary. It’s that it has sustained a level of cooking and hospitality over twenty-plus years without getting complacent or chasing trends. Donna Moodie has been nominated for James Beard awards, which the food press tends to mention and then forget. The regulars who fill this room on weeknights haven’t forgotten.
The service is attentive without being performative. Our server knew the menu well, didn’t oversell anything, and timed the courses without being asked. That level of floor management is rarer than it should be.
Marjorie is on 14th Avenue, a few blocks off the main Broadway corridor, which means you won’t stumble into it by accident. You have to mean to go. That’s exactly the kind of restaurant it is.