Oconto Falls, Wis. – U.S. District Judge Byron Conway issued a 47‑page decision Friday dismissing all six remaining claims filed by former students who alleged sexual misconduct, grooming and assault by staff members at Oconto Falls High School. The judge concluded that the school board, as a municipal entity, is responsible only for its own actions and not for the conduct of individual employees unless a specific policy or custom can be shown to have caused the violation.
Claims and plaintiffs
The lawsuit, originally filed by a trio of former students, grew to include six active plaintiffs who asserted that the district failed to act on reports of inappropriate relationships, locker‑room intrusions, improper physical contact, dress‑code requirements and sexual assault. Plaintiffs argued that the district’s inaction violated their constitutional right to bodily integrity under the Fourteenth Amendment and Title IX.
Judge’s legal analysis
Judge Conway wrote that “a legal claim for relief requires more than allegations that something bad happened.” He explained that for a municipal entity to be liable under 42 U.S.C. § 1983 or Title IX, plaintiffs must plausibly allege that a district policy or custom caused the constitutional violation. The court found none of the plaintiffs could meet that burden.
Specific findings included:
- Amanda Watzka – No evidence the district had a policy that motivated the alleged abuse, nor that she knew of any such policy that would have deterred her from reporting.
- Brooke LaCount – No proof the board was deliberately indifferent or that a policy existed to shield a teacher’s alleged assault.
- Grace Williams – The board had no knowledge of a policy or custom that would link the alleged assault to district liability.
- Kayla Kasper – The alleged conduct, while inappropriate, did not rise to the level of a constitutional violation and was not tied to any board policy.
- Jesse Kasal – Although the conduct may constitute sexual assault, the plaintiff failed to show it resulted from a district policy or custom.
- “D.P.” – Unwanted shoulder massages were deemed offensive but not sexual assault and did not meet the threshold for a Fourteenth Amendment claim.
The judge also rejected the plaintiffs’ Title IX retaliation claims, finding no evidence of district retaliation.
Context and next steps
Two of the staff members mentioned in the lawsuit have faced criminal proceedings. Former teacher Brynn Larsen was sentenced to two years in prison after a conviction for sexual assault, and former employee Gayle Gander faces multiple sexual‑assault charges with a plea hearing scheduled for March 9.
With the federal claims dismissed, the plaintiffs may seek to pursue any remaining state‑law claims, though the ruling makes clear that establishing district liability will require a demonstrable policy or custom that directly caused the alleged harm.
Community response
School officials reiterated that the district is not responsible for the actions of individual employees and emphasized ongoing efforts to protect students. The district has not named staff members who have not been criminally charged.
Local parents and community members expressed a mix of relief that the legal process is moving forward and concern that the underlying incidents highlight the need for vigilant safeguarding policies in schools.
Original reporting: FOX 11 WLUK Green Bay (local) — read the source article.