Charleston, WV — Governor Patrick Morrisey on Tuesday called on the West Virginia House of Delegates to begin impeachment proceedings against State Auditor Mark Hunt. The request follows a federal indictment that accuses Hunt of scheming to steal multiple properties by improperly issuing tax deeds, as well as a month‑long investigation by the West Virginia Division of Motor Vehicles (DMV) into Hunt’s auto dealership, After Hours.
Federal indictment details
The U.S. Attorney for the Southern District of West Virginia announced that Hunt faces ten charges, including fraud and theft of property. Prosecutors allege Hunt orchestrated the transfer of nine properties in Kanawha and Boone counties to a special counsel in his office, Robert Lisle Johns, who was hired in June of last year. The indictment also names four of Hunt’s staff members:
- David Keith Cole, 57 – deputy chief of staff and office manager of Hunt’s law firm
- Frederic Scott Caudill, 59 – general counsel for the auditor’s office
- Robert Lisle Johns, 66 – special counsel and business associate of Hunt
- Marie Ann Hoffman, 66 – employee accused of submitting fraudulent government timecards
According to the filing, Hoffman falsified timecards to claim hours worked at Hunt’s law firm, and Cole approved those cards with Hunt’s knowledge. The indictment further alleges that Caudill and Cole created and issued false paperwork to the FBI during its investigation of disputed tax deeds.
DMV investigation and dealer license suspension
Separately, the DMV launched an investigation after receiving a consumer complaint about After Hours. While reviewing dealership and DMV records and interviewing witnesses, investigators uncovered “significant and unexplained anomalies” in the dealership’s paperwork that could violate state and federal laws, including tax statutes. The DMV responded by suspending the dealer’s license pending further review.
Governor Morrisey said the two investigations are distinct but both raise serious concerns about the integrity of a statewide elected official. “Those issues are completely separate from the indictment announced yesterday,” he said in a statement. “The DMV’s investigation started because of a consumer complaint. As the Division dug into the dealership’s and DMV records and interviewed witnesses, they identified significant and unexplained anomalies that implicate potential violations of state and federal laws.”
Governor’s call for impeachment
Emphasizing his duty to protect public trust, Morrisey declared, “As Governor, I believe I have a duty to preserve the public integrity of the state and its officials.” He directed the DMV commissioner to forward the investigation findings to the U.S. attorney’s office and pledged to work with the Speaker’s office to move the impeachment process forward “as expeditiously as possible.”
The West Virginia Constitution allows the House of Delegates to consider articles of impeachment against any state officer for “misconduct in office.” If the House votes to impeach, the Senate would conduct a trial. No such action has been taken against an auditor in recent state history.
Responses and next steps
Auditor Hunt has maintained his innocence, issuing a statement on Monday that he will cooperate with investigators and defend himself against the charges. Legal analysts note that the combination of a federal indictment and a state‑level investigation could create significant political pressure, but the ultimate decision rests with the legislature.
State lawmakers are expected to convene in the coming weeks to discuss the governor’s request. The House Judiciary Committee, which oversees impeachment matters, will likely hold a hearing to review the evidence presented by the DMV and the federal prosecutors.
Local officials and advocacy groups have voiced mixed reactions. The West Virginia Taxpayers Association praised the governor’s swift action, calling it “a necessary step to uphold accountability.” Conversely, the West Virginia Democratic Party warned that “political motivations should not override due process.” Both sides agree that transparency and adherence to constitutional procedures are essential.
As the story develops, residents of Kanawha, Boone and the broader state will be watching closely to see how their elected officials respond to allegations of fraud and potential abuse of public office.
Original reporting: WCHS Eyewitness News Charleston (local) — read the source article.