TOLEDO, Ohio – A visiting judge has thrown out a civil suit that accused Lucas County Probate Court Judge Jack Puffenberger of using public funds to promote his son’s judicial campaign. The case, filed by state‑representative candidate David Karmol, alleged that ads aired in 2025 without the senior judge’s first name gave an unfair advantage to his son, Tom Puffenberger, who was running for the same probate seat.
Judge’s ruling
In a written opinion, the visiting judge concluded that the advertisements in question were public service announcements. The judge noted that, while the ads mentioned the last name “Puffenberger,” they did not specifically endorse any candidate and therefore could not be deemed illegal use of taxpayer money. The ruling also stated that any indirect benefit to a candidate sharing the same surname was speculative and not sufficient to sustain the lawsuit.
Judge Puffenberger’s son, Tom Puffenberger, ultimately won the probate court election, while David Karmol was not successful in his bid for the state‑house seat.
Background of the dispute
The lawsuit originated after Karmol claimed that the ads, which aired on local television and radio, were designed to boost the younger Puffenberger’s visibility among voters. Karmol argued that the use of county resources for the ads violated Ohio law prohibiting public officials from leveraging taxpayer money for partisan purposes.
During the proceedings, the court examined the content of the advertisements, the timing of their broadcast, and the funding source. The visiting judge found that the ads were funded through the county’s standard public‑information budget, which is intended for community outreach and informational programming.
Implications for local governance
The dismissal underscores the importance of clear guidelines for public‑service messaging and the need for officials to separate informational content from campaign activity. County officials have reiterated their commitment to transparency and to following Ohio statutes governing the use of public funds.
Lucas County Commissioners have not indicated any intention to change the current public‑information budgeting process, but the case may prompt a review of policies to ensure that future communications are unmistakably nonpartisan.
Reactions
David Karmol, who filed the suit, expressed disappointment with the decision, stating that “the ruling overlooks the real impact these ads had on the election.” He indicated he may consider further legal avenues if new evidence emerges.
Judge Jack Puffenberger, who was named as a defendant, declined to comment on the matter, citing judicial ethics rules that limit public discussion of ongoing cases.
Legal experts familiar with Ohio election law noted that the case highlights the fine line between public information and political promotion, especially in smaller jurisdictions where officials often wear multiple hats.
What’s next?
With the lawsuit dismissed, the county’s public‑information program will continue its regular operations. Residents who have concerns about the use of taxpayer dollars for communications are encouraged to contact the Lucas County Auditor’s Office for clarification on budgeting practices.
The decision also serves as a reminder for candidates and officeholders to maintain strict separation between official duties and campaign activities, preserving public trust in local institutions.
Original reporting: 13abc WTVG Toledo (news) — read the source article.