According to Lookout Eugene‑Springfield, a Multnomah County resident has filed a federal civil‑rights lawsuit in the U.S. District Court in Eugene, claiming the University of Oregon (UO) revoked a job offer after a background check revealed a misdemeanor conviction stemming from a protest against the war in Gaza. The case is significant for Eugene residents because it tests how public institutions balance campus safety policies with constitutional free‑speech protections.
The complaint states that Nic Francisco‑Kaho’onei applied in August 2024 for the position of program director of UO’s Women’s Center, a campus hub that provides gender‑related resources and events. UO extended the offer in November 2024, which Francisco‑Kaho’onei accepted. The offer was contingent on a background check, which later flagged a misdemeanor arrest for disorderly conduct recorded in April 2024.
Lane County Circuit Court records, cited by the lawsuit, show that Francisco‑Kaho’onei was charged with second‑degree disorderly conduct after blocking traffic on Interstate 5 during a pro‑Palestine demonstration. After changing a not‑guilty plea to guilty, they were convicted on Nov. 27, 2024, ordered to pay a $50 fine and complete 40 hours of community service. The plaintiff argues the charge was a civil‑disobedience act protected by the First Amendment.
UO initially announced the hiring internally, but on Dec. 4, 2024, the university notified Francisco‑Kaho’onei that the offer was being withdrawn because the charges had not yet been adjudicated. After the conviction was entered, the university sent a second notice on Dec. 19, 2024, stating the “very recent conviction is relevant to the Program Director position.” The complaint says the university did not explain how the misdemeanor related to the job duties.
The lawsuit alleges that UO, along with vice presidents Mark Schmelz and Angela Lauer Chong and associate vice president Jimmy Howard, violated Francisco‑Kaho’onei’s First Amendment rights and equal‑protection guarantees. The plaintiff seeks a jury trial, damages for lost wages, emotional distress, attorney fees, and a court declaration of constitutional violations.
UO’s Human Resources FAQ, referenced in the filing, notes that a criminal conviction does not automatically disqualify an applicant. The university says each case is evaluated based on the offense’s nature, gravity, time elapsed, and relevance to the position. The complaint contends that the university’s decision contradicts this policy.
Before applying to UO, Francisco‑Kaho’onei served as director of Portland State University’s Women’s Resource Center. In April 2025, after the UO dispute, they were terminated from that role without explanation, a development reported by the Portland Mercury and linked by the plaintiff to their public support for Palestine.
What’s next: The case was filed on Nov. 19, 2024, and will proceed to a jury trial, though no trial date has been set. Both parties will continue to exchange pleadings, and the university may face additional scrutiny of its hiring practices as the lawsuit moves forward.
Sources: lookouteugene-springfield.com