The Tuscumbia City Council met Monday night and voted 4 to 2 to terminate the existing application process for the city’s police chief. Council members said the decision will allow the city to rewrite the application, review it with the clerk, mayor and city attorney, and then restart the search for a candidate who can provide strong, knowledgeable, decisive, and competent leadership.
Why the process is being reset
Mayor and chief administrator Mike Smith emphasized that the city must enforce state and local laws effectively. “It is time for this process to end and a new process to begin,” resident Pam Hodges told the council, echoing the mayor’s call for leadership that upholds the rule of law.
Councilmember Jennifer Bennetch (District 3) added that after seven months of reviewing applications, the council believes a fresh start is the best path forward. “We need to step back, redo the process, and hear how each applicant responds to the interview,” she said.
Interim chief’s record
Since interim chief Steve Higginbotham took over in April, following Tony Logan’s departure, he has been with the department for 18 years and has 26 years of law‑enforcement experience overall. Supporters highlighted his achievements, including securing a K‑9 unit and obtaining several grants for department upgrades.
However, a few residents and a council member expressed concerns about Higginbotham’s past, describing it as “troubled.” Those criticisms were part of the heated discussion that led to the council’s vote.
Next steps for the application
The council will work with the city clerk, mayor and city attorney to revise the wording of the application. Once the revised application is approved, it will be posted for public review and the city will reopen the search for qualified candidates.
There is currently no timeline for how long Tuscumbia may be without a permanent chief, but council members indicated they expect the new process to move forward promptly.
Community response
Residents at the meeting voiced a desire for transparency and community involvement. One council member said, “We want everyone to be a part of the discussion,” underscoring the council’s commitment to hearing public input as the search resumes.
The council’s decision reflects a broader commitment to ensuring the police department has leadership that can protect public safety while respecting the community’s values and constitutional rights.
Original reporting: WAFF 48 Huntsville (news) — read the source article.