People outside Cincinnati know Montgomery Inn from the ribs. People inside Cincinnati mostly know the Boathouse location on the riverfront, and they have opinions about it — usually something like, “It’s a tourist place, isn’t it?” That assumption is worth examining before you write it off.
The Boathouse sits on the Ohio River in Columbia-Tusculum, a few miles east of downtown, and yes, it’s large. Very large. The main dining room seats several hundred people, and on a Saturday night in summer the parking lot fills with a mix of out-of-towners, office parties, and older couples who’ve been coming for thirty years. That’s not the whole picture.
Montgomery Inn has been in the same family since Ted Gregory opened the original Montgomey Road location in 1951. The Boathouse opened in 1989. The ribs are still slow-cooked, still brushed with their proprietary Sauerbraten sauce — a sweet, tangy glaze that doesn’t taste like anything you’d get out of a bottle at the grocery store — and still served with a small loaf of onion bread that shows up at the table before you’ve even decided what you want. That bread is worth coming for on its own.
The menu is straightforward. Ribs by the slab or half slab, chicken, shrimp, some combination plates. Prices run from about $22 for a half slab up to $55 or so for a full slab with sides. It’s not cheap, but portions are substantial and the kitchen doesn’t rush you. The coleslaw is creamy and cold and understated. The fries are fine. The ribs themselves — fall-off-the-bone is an overused phrase, but they do pull clean from the bone without being mushy, which is harder than it sounds.
The river view from the dining room is legitimately good. If you go on a weeknight in spring or early fall, the place quiets down considerably, and you can sit near the windows and watch towboats push upstream in the dusk without feeling like you’re eating in an airport concourse. That version of the Boathouse is quite different from the Saturday night version, and it’s the one more locals should try.
What people get wrong about Montgomery Inn is confusing “famous” with “past its peak.” The ribs are still made the same way they were fifty years ago, which in this case is a compliment. This isn’t a place coasting on nostalgia — it’s a place that happened to get well-known because the product was consistently good and stayed that way. Cincinnati has a lot of restaurants that opened with buzz and faded. Montgomery Inn has outlasted most of them.
It is a little formal in a mid-century American way — tablecloths, attentive servers, the kind of place where people occasionally wear a sport coat. That’s not a complaint. It’s just useful to know going in. Reservations are worth making on weekends. Parking is free in the lot along the river.
If you go once expecting to dismiss it as a tourist stop and find yourself thinking about those ribs two days later, that’s a pretty common outcome.