Milford, N.H. — New Hampshire’s Judicial Conduct Committee (JCC) has filed formal charges against 9th Circuit Court Judge Todd Prevett for alleged misconduct in a family‑court guardianship proceeding. The charges stem from a December 2024 case in which a mother sought to restore her parental rights.
Allegations of Bias and Improper Investigation
The JCC’s complaint asserts that Judge Prevett denied the mother’s request, citing criminal cases against her from more than a decade ago, including offenses in Massachusetts. The committee says he failed to explain how those old cases were relevant to her current effort to reunite with her child.
According to the filing, Judge Prevett also made a “highly critical” assessment of the mother, describing her as “callous, snide and immature.” The documents allege he displayed “expressions of hostility and disdain” during proceedings.
Further, the complaint alleges that Judge Prevett independently investigated the mother’s criminal history beyond the evidence permitted in court, a step the committee says violates the duty to act impartially.
Supreme Court Intervention
The mother appealed Judge Prevett’s decision, and the New Hampshire Supreme Court intervened, removing him from the case and assigning a new judge. The high court’s order highlighted concerns about bias and partiality, noting that such appellate reversals are exceptionally rare.
Retired Massachusetts juvenile court judge Carol Erskine, interviewed by News 9, called the Supreme Court’s action “exceptionally rare” and warned that the JCC complaint is “well laid out,” suggesting that Judge Prevett could face significant discipline if the allegations are substantiated.
Prior Conduct Issues
This is not the first time Judge Prevett’s conduct has been questioned. In 2024, he was accused of using his judicial position to request a “favor” that allowed him access to a courthouse closed for a professional day, where he then filed paperwork in his own guardianship case. He admitted to the allegation, received a formal reprimand, and was ordered to be mentored by a senior circuit court judge.
Next Steps in the Process
The JCC’s report gave Judge Prevett 30 days to file a response; that deadline has now passed. News 9 has reached out to the committee for an update on whether a response has been filed, but has not yet received a reply.
Should the committee move forward with disciplinary action, possible outcomes range from a formal reprimand to removal from the bench, depending on the findings of any subsequent hearing.
Community Impact
The case underscores the importance of impartiality in family‑court proceedings, where parents’ rights and children’s welfare are at stake. Local advocates emphasize that confidence in the judicial system hinges on judges adhering to ethical standards and avoiding any appearance of bias.
Residents of Milford and the broader New Hampshire community will be watching the outcome closely, as it may set precedent for how judicial conduct is enforced in family‑court matters across the state.
Original reporting: WMUR (Hearst) – local news — read the source article.