Durant, Oklahoma – A theft that shocked a local collector has led to criminal charges for three men from Pauls Valley. According to court documents and statements from the Durant Police Department, a Phillips 66 sign and a Citiservice sign, together worth roughly $7,000, were removed from a property just across the highway from the police station.
How the theft unfolded
The incident occurred on Sunday when a tenant who rents part of the property heard a noise and saw individuals loading the two vintage signs onto a vehicle. The tenant promptly called the police, and Sgt. Brandon Mitchell of the Durant Police Department arrived to investigate.
“On the property itself, there’s a tenant that rents from the property owner and he’s the one that actually called it in,” Mitchell said.
Police were able to track the suspect vehicle within a mile of the scene, following the tenant’s description of its direction. The investigation led to the arrest of Budle Johnson, James Johnson, and Joseph Chesnutt, all residents of Pauls Valley.
Charges and background
Each defendant faces three counts: grand larceny, knowingly receiving or concealing stolen property, and conspiracy to commit a felony. Court filings note that all three have lengthy criminal records, and the documents allege that they agreed in advance to commit the theft.
Both signs have since been recovered and returned to the owner, who collects vintage signage as a hobby. In a practical move to protect the Phillips 66 sign, the owner now parks his truck directly on top of it.
Police advice for property owners
Sgt. Mitchell emphasized that property owners can take proactive steps to safeguard their belongings. “If they can put up security cameras, well‑lit areas, having somebody maybe on site like this individual did that, you know, is watching the property, those are all good,” he explained.
The incident underscores the importance of vigilance, especially for owners of valuable or unique items. The Durant Police Department encourages anyone who witnesses suspicious activity to report it immediately.
Community response
The owner expressed relief that the signs were recovered and praised the quick response of the tenant and law‑enforcement. “I’m glad the signs are back,” he said, noting that his collection is a personal passion.
Local residents have voiced support for the police’s swift action and have called for increased security measures in the area, particularly for properties that house collectible items.
Next steps
The three defendants will appear in court for arraignment, where they will enter pleas to the charges. If convicted, they face significant penalties under Oklahoma’s grand‑larceny statutes.
Durant Police continue to investigate any related leads and remind the public that reporting crimes promptly can make a decisive difference in recovering stolen property and bringing offenders to justice.
Original reporting: KXII News 12 (Gray) — read the source article.