KNOXVILLE, Tenn. — A recent audit by the Tennessee Comptroller’s Office shows that the Tennessee Highway Patrol (THP) failed to properly complete more than half of its mandated evidence reviews over the two‑year period from 2023 to 2025. Of the 126 reviews required, 40 were not performed at all and another 34 were done incorrectly, leaving the agency with a correct completion rate of just 41%.
Audit details expose procedural gaps
The audit report breaks down the deficiencies: 24 reviews lacked proof that the reviewer examined the related case files, four did not explain noted discrepancies, and four were missing essential information such as case numbers, evidence type, and confirmation that the evidence was located. Additionally, one review was performed by an individual without proper authority and another was not finished within the required timeframe.
According to the comptroller, the root of the problem lies in the THP manual, which spreads evidence‑review requirements across multiple sections instead of consolidating them in a dedicated chapter. This lack of clarity left district captains and evidence custodians uncertain about who was responsible for conducting the reviews.
Training shortfalls identified
The audit also uncovered that many evidence custodians received little formal instruction. Some relied on personal experience, on‑the‑job shadowing, or informal consultation with peers. Several custodians reported that they never received structured written guidance for duties such as vehicle‑storage‑lot procedures.
THP response and planned improvements
THP management concurred with the findings and announced a comprehensive overhaul of its evidence‑custody processes. “We are in the process of refining our evidence custodian processes and training, which include updates to the Evidence Manual,” the agency said. The revised manual will establish clear standards, procedures, responsibilities, and formal training requirements. It will be developed in coordination with current evidence custodians and the Research, Planning, and Development Division.
District captains will receive a new district‑level review process that requires them to verify that all evidence audits, inventories, and required reviews are fully completed, with documented findings and sign‑offs. This added layer of oversight is intended to ensure accountability and prevent future lapses.
Why proper evidence reviews matter
Evidence reviews are a cornerstone of the criminal‑justice system. Accurate documentation and verification help preserve the chain of custody, protect the rights of victims and defendants, and support prosecutors in securing convictions. By tightening its procedures, THP aims to uphold public safety and maintain community confidence in law‑enforcement operations.
State officials praised the audit’s thoroughness and expressed optimism that the forthcoming changes will bring the agency into compliance with best practices. “Ensuring that our evidence handling meets the highest standards is essential for the rule of law and for the families who depend on swift, fair justice,” the comptroller’s office stated.
While the audit highlights significant shortcomings, the proactive steps announced by THP demonstrate a commitment to transparency and continuous improvement—principles that align with the values of responsible governance and the safety of Tennessee’s neighborhoods.
Original reporting: Action News 5 WMC (Gray) — read the source article.