On September 25, 2026, the Sheridan Broncos suffered a decisive 38‑0 defeat at the hands of the Natrona County Mustangs, ending a remarkable 59‑game winning streak that had defined the program for years. The loss also halted a 22‑game road winning streak, which was tied for the second‑longest run in Wyoming high‑school football history.
Game Overview
The Broncos fell behind early, trailing 10‑0 before they could execute a single offensive play. Natrona County’s defense forced a fumble on the opening kickoff, which set the tone for the remainder of the contest. Throughout the game, the Mustangs dominated both sides of the ball, never allowing Sheridan to cross the goal line.
First Quarter
– 0:10 – Cooper Rogers connected with Cooper Cox on a 23‑yard pass, moving the ball from the Natrona County 25‑yard line to the 48‑yard line.
– 0:25 – Patton True rushed 13 yards from Sheridan’s 26‑yard line to the 13‑yard line.
– 0:35 – Easton Hiday kicked a 26‑yard field goal, putting Natrona County up 3‑0.
– 0:44 – Natrona County kicked off; Michael McMullen fumbled, and Carter Rohrer recovered.
– 1:06 – True added a 16‑yard run, advancing from Sheridan’s 19‑yard line to the 3‑yard line.
– 1:18 – True punched in a 2‑yard touchdown run, extending Natrona County’s lead to 10‑0.
– 1:27 – Braxten Crow completed a 15‑yard pass, moving the ball from Sheridan’s 17‑yard line to the 32‑yard line.
Second Quarter
– 1:40 – Kason Weber recorded a sack on Braxten Crow.
– 1:50 – True broke free for a 19‑yard run, taking the ball from Sheridan’s 38‑yard line to the 19‑yard line.
– 2:05 – Hiday missed a 43‑yard field‑goal attempt.
– 2:14 – Brodey Wilcox rushed 20 yards from Natrona County’s 46‑yard line to Sheridan’s 34‑yard line.
– 2:25 – Wilcox scored on a 34‑yard touchdown run, making the score 17‑0.
– 2:37 – Hiday missed a 59‑yard field‑goal attempt.
Third Quarter
– 2:47 – Weber intercepted Dominic Destefano.
– 3:02 – True attempted a 1‑yard run but fumbled; the ball was recovered by an unspecified player.
– 3:20 – Logan Rager sacked Cooper Rogers.
– 3:30 – Rogers threw a 22‑yard pass to Cooper Cox, moving the ball from Sheridan’s 39‑yard line to the 17‑yard line.
– 3:40 – Wilcox added a 16‑yard touchdown run, pushing Natrona County’s lead to 24‑0.
– 3:55 – True capped the quarter with a 40‑yard touchdown run, extending the margin to 31‑0.
Fourth Quarter
– 4:07 – Natrona County recovered a fumble on a lateral play.
– 4:20 – True finished the scoring with a 3‑yard touchdown run, sealing a 38‑0 shutout.
The loss marks the first shutout defeat for Sheridan since the 2014 playoff semi‑finals, also against Natrona County. While the Broncos struggled offensively, the Mustangs’ defense and balanced attack proved too much for the Sheridan squad.
Historical Context
Sheridan’s 59‑game winning streak had been a point of pride for the community, showcasing the program’s consistency and competitiveness. The 22‑game road streak, tied for the second‑longest in state history, underscored the team’s ability to win away from home. Both streaks ending in a single game is a stark reminder of the unpredictable nature of high‑school sports.
Local fans and alumni expressed disappointment on social media, but many also praised the Mustangs for their disciplined performance. Coaches from both schools highlighted the importance of sportsmanship and the lessons learned from the outcome.
Looking Ahead
Sheridan’s coaching staff will regroup and focus on adjustments for the remainder of the season, emphasizing fundamentals and resilience. Natrona County, buoyed by the victory, will look to build on this momentum as they continue their campaign.
Both programs remain integral parts of the Sheridan and Natrona County communities, offering student‑athletes opportunities for growth, teamwork, and community engagement.
Original reporting: Sheridan Media (Sheridan WY) — read the source article.
