Price County, Wisconsin – Sheriff Brian Schmidt, a Republican who has served as the county’s top law‑enforcement officer since 2009, is again the focus of serious allegations. Several women have publicly detailed complaints they filed in the 1990s, accusing Schmidt of sexual assault, harassment, and inappropriate conduct while he was a deputy.
Allegations surface amid defamation lawsuit
Schmidt sued political rival John Brylski for defamation in 2022, asserting he had never been disciplined or accused of misconduct. In that filing, he claimed he “has never been disciplined in his position or accused of improper conduct, nor has Sheriff Schmidt been accused of any ‘illegal’ actions or misconduct during his entire career.” The recent disclosures directly challenge that statement.
Women recount separate incidents
One accuser, Tammy Hastings, who now chairs the Price County Republican Party, alleges that in July 1990 Schmidt, then a deputy, sexually assaulted and impregnated her in his squad car while she was 19. Hastings says she filed three complaints with the sheriff’s office in the 1990s, but the records are missing.
Another woman, Suzy Jo Petersen, says that in 1995, as a 14‑year‑old high‑school freshman, she was detained in the back seat of Schmidt’s squad car for more than half an hour, touched on the leg, and subjected to inappropriate comments about her appearance and friends. Petersen’s account is said to have led to a disciplinary hearing before a closed Price County Board committee, and a former sheriff removed Schmidt from the county’s DARE officer position because of the incident.
Investigative findings and missing records
Wisconsin Watch spent months reviewing court, agency, and personnel files, interviewing over 70 individuals, and tracing the chain of custody for alleged disciplinary documents. The investigation found corroborating testimony from former county officials and an HR administrator who recalled drafting charges related to the 1995 incident, though the county cannot locate the original records.
A third woman, speaking on video with a private investigator in 2024, described a sexual relationship with Schmidt that began in the late 1980s when he was a deputy and she was under the legal age of consent. Her mother corroborated details, including an alleged episode of physical abuse. Schmidt’s attorney, Robert Mihelich, denied the relationship and highlighted the woman’s criminal history.
Legal context and ongoing litigation
The allegations are now part of a federal lawsuit Schmidt filed against Brylski, arguing that the claims raise First Amendment issues. Brylski initially posted a statement apologizing for his earlier accusations, but later retracted that apology, asserting he was coerced into issuing it.
Schmidt has declined multiple interview requests. His attorney maintains that the complaints were either never made or never communicated to Schmidt, and characterizes the women’s histories as undermining their credibility.
Community reaction and upcoming retirement
Schmidt announced in May that he will retire at the end of his term to spend more time with his family. The sheriff’s office, which serves a Northwoods community of roughly 14,000 residents, has not released any official comment on the new allegations.
Local officials say they have no records of the complaints or the disciplinary hearing cited by the women, though state law and county ordinances generally require retention of such documents. The lack of records has fueled community concern and calls for greater transparency in law‑enforcement oversight.
What’s next?
The defamation case and the federal lawsuit remain pending. As the legal process unfolds, residents of Price County will be watching closely to see whether the allegations lead to formal investigations, policy changes, or further court action.
Original reporting: Wisconsin Watch — read the source article.