Price County, Wisconsin – A deep‑dive investigation by Wisconsin Watch has brought to light multiple accusations of sexual misconduct against Sheriff Brian Schmidt dating back to the 1990s. The probe, which began after a 2022 tip from retired deputy John Brylski, uncovered testimonies from two women who say Schmidt assaulted them while he was a deputy, as well as evidence that county records of related complaints and disciplinary actions are missing.
Background of the allegations
In December 2022, Brylski, a former Outagamie County deputy who moved to Price County in 2019, emailed Wisconsin Watch with claims that Schmidt had abused an illegal immigrant teenager and impregnated a 19‑year‑old in his squad car. Brylski posted the allegations on his Facebook page and later ran a write‑in campaign for sheriff in November 2022. Schmidt sued Brylski for defamation a month before the election; the case settled in July 2024, and Brylski issued a public apology.
Wisconsin Watch did not stop there. The newsroom interviewed more than 70 sources, reviewed hundreds of pages of court, agency and personnel records, and tracked down former county officials to verify the claims.
Women’s accounts
Two women, Tammy Hastings and Suzy Jo Petersen, shared detailed recollections. Hastings said that in 1990, while she was underage and drinking with friends, Schmidt arrived in uniform at her Phillips apartment, drove her 15 miles to a secluded field, and sexually assaulted her in his squad car. Petersen, then 14, recounted a traffic stop in which Schmidt kept her in the back of his squad car for at least half an hour, made comments about her appearance, and touched her thigh over her snow pants.
Schmidt has acknowledged a traffic stop involving Petersen but denies that she was ever in the back seat. He also admits he is the father of Hastings’ daughter but claims the encounter was consensual. Multiple witnesses, however, recall Hastings describing the incident as an assault as early as 1990.
Missing records and county response
Despite the women’s statements, Schmidt’s personnel file contained no clear indication of complaints. A cryptic reference to “L. Millot” led investigators to former HR administrator Lauri Millot, who confirmed she drafted a formal complaint against Schmidt in 1995 recommending serious discipline. The outcome of that complaint remains unknown.
County officials were unable to locate records of the disciplinary hearing or the three complaints Hastings says she filed before and after her daughter’s birth. Wisconsin law requires county records to be retained for at least seven years, and Price County’s 2011 ordinance specifically mandates that internal investigations be kept until after the subject’s death. No evidence was found that the county had requested destruction of Schmidt’s personnel records.
Legal and community implications
Schmidt’s attorney has used the absence of records to argue that the women’s stories are false, while refusing to grant an interview. Wisconsin Watch plans to continue investigating any further allegations of sexual misconduct involving law‑enforcement officials in the region.
Community members and local leaders are urged to consider the importance of transparent record‑keeping and robust oversight of public safety officials. Those with additional information are invited to contact the newsroom at [email protected].
About Wisconsin Watch
Wisconsin Watch is a nonprofit, nonpartisan newsroom dedicated to investigative reporting across the state. Readers can subscribe to newsletters for original stories and a weekly news roundup.
Original reporting: Wisconsin Watch — read the source article.