Pete’s Apizza on 14th Street has been making New Haven-style pizza in Washington since 2010, which is long enough that the debate over whether it’s the best pizza in D.C. has had time to calcify into genuine tribal allegiance.
Jim Loznicka opened the place with a premise that is either obvious or heretical depending on your position: that D.C. deserved a proper apizza, the thin-crust, coal-fired style from New Haven that Frank Pepe perfected and that Yale students have been claiming credit for appreciating ever since. The oven runs hot — around 650 degrees — and the char on the bottom of a Pete’s pie is not incidental. It is the point.
Loznicka is not a flashy operator. He’s the kind of owner who shows up, keeps the menu focused, and resists the urge to add truffle anything. The original 14th Street location, in Columbia Heights, has the feel of a neighborhood restaurant that became a destination without really trying to. The room is loud on a Friday, the booths fill up fast, and the server who’s been there since roughly the Obama administration will tell you, without excessive drama, that the wait is what it is.
The menu doesn’t require much navigation. Order a pie, pick your toppings, decide whether you want a salad. The white clam pizza — a nod to Pepe’s signature — is the thing most people are there for, and it earns the attention: briny, garlicky, with enough olive oil that the crust stays interesting rather than drying out. The mozzarella pies are strong too, the sauce bright and not oversweetened, the crust maintaining that signature chew-to-crisp ratio that separates real apizza from the round, doughy approximations you find elsewhere.
A pie runs between $15 and $22 depending on toppings, which is fair for the quality and the neighborhood. Pete’s has a second location in Friendship Heights that opened a few years later and operates on a similar logic: not trying to be a scene, just trying to get the pizza right.
The regulars at Pete’s are the kind of people who have opinions. You’ll hear someone at the next table say, with complete confidence, that the coal oven makes all the difference, and they won’t be wrong. You’ll also overhear the counter-argument that a wood-fired place in NoMa is doing something more interesting, and that person will not be entirely wrong either. This is the food conversation D.C. has been having about Pete’s for fifteen years, and it shows no sign of resolution.
Go on a weeknight if you want to hear yourself think. Go on a weekend if you don’t mind waiting near the door while someone finishes the last of their clam pie with unhurried deliberateness. Either way, the pizza will be what it’s always been: credible, consistent, and worth the argument.