On Tuesday, the Olathe City Council voted 7‑0 to send the proposed 476‑unit apartment complex near Heritage Park back to the Olathe Planning Commission for further work. The council’s decision follows a developer concession to reduce the height of the northwest building and a request for stronger privacy screening and a deeper traffic analysis.
Project overview
Rodrock Development plans to build seven four‑story apartment buildings on roughly 25 acres northwest of 159th Street and Pflumm Road. The development, called Residences at Heritage Park, would feature mostly one‑ and two‑bedroom rentals, garages, a pool, a clubhouse and a direct connection to the Heritage Trail. The site currently sits in a business‑park zone, which permits structures up to 144 feet tall.
Neighborhood concerns
Neighbors in the Reserve at Heritage and Symphony of the Reserve subdivisions have voiced worries for months about building height, traffic, and the impact on their single‑family homes. A protest petition filed after the planning commission’s October 12 vote required a minimum of six council “yes” votes for approval.
Resident Joseph Maxwell, who spoke at the planning commission meeting, warned that a 50‑foot building would block sunrise views: “Fifty‑foot buildings in the backyard means no more sunrises. No more big sky.” He and two other nearby residents reiterated these concerns at the council meeting, noting that three homeowners’ associations representing 381 homes had sent a letter outlining their objections.
Council’s response and developer’s concession
City staff indicated that rezoning the property from a business park to an R‑4 medium‑density multifamily zone would require a lower building height. In response, Rodrock agreed to lower the furthest northwest building to two stories, though the impact on the total unit count was not disclosed.
Councilmember Robyn Essex, who walked the site with residents, said the transition from single‑family homes to four‑story apartments was abrupt: “There is no transition. It just goes, boom, R‑1 to all of a sudden four stories.” Councilmembers also asked Rodrock to explore additional landscaping and screening to buffer the apartments, garages, and parking from nearby homes.
Traffic considerations
Traffic impacts were a major focus. Resident Carrie DeMaio expressed doubt that Pflumm Road could handle additional vehicles, stating, “I think it would be wiser to wait until Pflumm’s expanded.” The development would feature three entrances on Pflumm, each requiring turn‑lane improvements, but broader upgrades between 151st and 159th streets are not included in the city’s Capital Improvement Plan.
Senior City Planner Jessica Schuler cited a traffic study projecting the apartments would generate about 25 % fewer peak‑hour trips than the previously approved business‑park development for the site. Councilmember Matthew Schoonover asked for a clearer picture of travel times, noting his concern was more about commute duration than raw vehicle counts.
Developer’s commitment
Rodrock representative Judd Claussen emphasized the company’s local roots, describing the team as “a hometown, quality generational builder dedicated to building great communities,” and pledged to explore more substantial landscaping as part of the final plan.
Next steps
Councilmember Jeff Creighton, who first suggested remanding the project, said the council hopes the revisions will produce a better outcome for neighbors. “We have to be very clear to the planning commission,” he said. The planning commission will reconsider the revised proposal at a future meeting.
In related news, the Overland Park Planning Commission recently approved a rezoning that will allow $1 million homes near Heritage Park, eight blocks away from the Olathe project, indicating continued growth pressure in the area.
Original reporting: Johnson County Post (Overland Park) — read the source article.