The Ohio House Republican Organizational Committee filed a petition with the Ohio Supreme Court on Wednesday seeking to have certain provisional ballots from Lucas County excluded from the final count of the 2026 midterm election. The legal challenge focuses on ballots cast by voters who were registered in a different county but voted provisionally at a polling place on Election Day.
Background on the contested race
The dispute centers on Ohio House District 44, where Republican Ed Schimmel and Democrat David Fournier are locked in a close contest. After the results from Ottawa and Wood counties were certified, Schimmel held a lead of fewer than 40 votes. The remaining votes from Lucas County could determine the final outcome, prompting the committee to act.
In Wood County, the Board of Elections certified Rick Rettig as the winner of District 75, a race the committee monitored closely. “Every vote really matters, and election integrity is extremely important,” said Matt Kelly, a spokesperson for the Ohio House Republican Organizational Committee.
Legal basis for the challenge
Kelly explained that the committee believes state law requires voters to cast their ballots at the board of elections or a designated location in the county where they are registered. “In the eyes of the law and the statute, those ballots should not be counted, as they were not cast in a legal way,” he said.
The committee’s petition asks the Ohio Supreme Court for clarification of the law and, ultimately, an order to discard the challenged provisional ballots. “We want to make sure every vote is counted and every vote that is cast legally is counted, and in extremely tight races like what we’re seeing in northwest Ohio, we make sure that these votes are counted and that the right votes are counted in the right way,” Kelly added.
Lucas County Board of Elections response
The Lucas County Board of Elections met Wednesday afternoon and indicated that, unless a court order is issued, it will continue counting ballots according to its standard procedures. No immediate decision was announced, and the board emphasized its commitment to following established election guidelines.
Implications for the district
If the Ohio Supreme Court grants the committee’s request, the removal of the provisional ballots could shift the margin in District 44, potentially altering which candidate will represent the district in the Ohio House of Representatives. The outcome will also set a precedent for how provisional ballots are treated in future Ohio elections.
Both campaigns have urged voters to stay informed as the legal process unfolds. The committee stresses that its actions are intended to protect the integrity of the election process, while opponents argue that the challenge could disenfranchise voters who exercised their right to vote provisionally.
Original reporting: 13abc WTVG Toledo (news) — read the source article.