Florence’s Restaurant on New Orleans Street has been feeding Broken Arrow since 1952, which makes it older than most of the people eating there on any given Tuesday.
The building looks like it survived several decades of Oklahoma weather, which it has. The sign out front is not trying to impress you. Neither is the menu, which runs to about two laminated pages and has not undergone a rebrand. That’s the whole point.
What you get at Florence’s is soul food done without ceremony. Fried chicken that arrives in a basket with a paper lining, still crackling from the oil. Chicken-fried steak that occupies a serious portion of the plate. Greens cooked down with pork until they taste like someone’s grandmother made them, which is more or less what happened. The corn bread comes in a small cast iron skillet. If you try to skip it on caloric grounds, you will regret this decision.
The catfish is worth calling out specifically. Cornmeal-crusted, fried properly, not greasy in the way that shortcuts make things greasy. It comes with a side of hot sauce on the table that has no label and no explanation, and you will put it on everything.
Lunch is the move here. The daily specials rotate and they’re usually written on a board near the register. The room fills up fast — a mix of construction workers, retired couples, and people who clearly come every week — and the staff moves through it all with the calm efficiency of people who have been doing this a long time, because they have. Turnover at Florence’s is not a thing that happens quickly. Some of these faces have been here for years.
Prices have gone up with everything else, but a full lunch plate still lands somewhere in the ten to fourteen dollar range, which for the quantity and quality of what you’re eating is not a figure that invites complaint. Dinner is available too, though lunch crowds tend to be the regulars, and there’s something to that. A place survives seven decades in one spot because a specific group of people decides it’s theirs. Florence’s has that.
It’s on New Orleans Street in a part of Broken Arrow that doesn’t get much coverage in roundups about the Rose District or whatever’s new downtown. That’s fine with Florence’s. It doesn’t need the coverage. The parking lot fills up anyway.
If you are expecting atmosphere in the design-forward sense, adjust expectations. What you get instead is a room that feels lived in because it is — vinyl seating, good light, the smell of a fryer that has been in continuous operation for generations. Some people find that charming. Some people find it honest. Those are probably the same people.
Go hungry. Order the catfish or the fried chicken. Get the corn bread. Come back next week and do it again. That is apparently the correct approach, based on the evidence of everyone already there when you arrive.