On Thursday, the Transport Workers Union filed a federal lawsuit in Manhattan challenging New York City’s newly signed law that will prohibit horse‑drawn carriage rides in Central Park by June 2028. The suit targets Mayor Zohran Mamdani and city officials, claiming the legislation unlawfully destroys the drivers’ businesses and ignores existing property interests and contracts.
Mayor’s rationale and safety record
Mayor Mamdani, a Democrat, signed the bill after the tragic death of 18‑year‑old Indian tourist Romanch Mahajan, who fell from a runaway carriage last spring. At the signing ceremony, the mayor praised the historic role horses played in the city’s development but argued that modern traffic, joggers, cyclists and other park users make the rides unsafe. “Our city has changed and now it is time for our laws to change, too,” he said.
The city has long regulated the industry with veterinary check‑ups, mandatory rest periods, and a retirement age for the animals. Mamdani’s administration says the new law builds on those protections, aiming to prevent future accidents while preserving public safety.
Drivers’ response and transition plan
Union head John Samuelsen, representing the carriage drivers, called the mayor’s approach “immediately cripple the owners, ignore property interests and contracts, and maybe compensate.” He argued that the city’s good‑intented safety measures should have been incorporated into the legislation rather than used as a basis for an outright ban.
City Hall has promised a career‑transition plan for affected workers, slated for release next April. The plan is said to include job‑training programs, educational pathways and stipends to help drivers move into new employment. Drivers remain skeptical, saying the future remains uncertain despite the mayor’s assurances.
Legal arguments
The lawsuit alleges that the ban violates the Constitution by depriving owners of their property without just compensation and that the city failed to follow proper legal procedures when enacting the law. The complaint names the mayor, the city’s law department and several other officials as defendants.
A spokesperson for the city’s law department said the office is reviewing the case and will respond in due course.
Community perspective
The carriage rides have long been a romantic symbol of New York’s past, drawing tourists from around the world. Animal‑welfare advocates argue the industry poses risks to both horses and the public, while supporters view the rides as a cherished tradition that supports families who depend on the work.
As the legal battle unfolds, the city’s next steps on the transition plan and any possible amendments to the ban will be closely watched by both sides of the debate.
Original reporting: WPBF (Treasure Coast / Hearst) — read the source article.