Mayor Justin Elicker’s administration has taken legal action against Westport Insurance Corporation, alleging the insurer failed to honor coverage for the city’s recent $30.5 million wrongful‑incarceration settlements with former inmates Marquis Jackson and Vernon Horn.
Background on the settlements
Jackson and Horn each spent nearly two decades behind bars after being convicted of a 1999 murder. Their convictions were later overturned when city police were found to have fabricated evidence and withheld exculpatory material. After their releases, both men sued the city – Horn in 2018 and Jackson in 2019 – and the city settled each case for $15.25 million in August.
Insurance coverage dispute
The city’s lawsuit, filed in Connecticut federal court on Nov. 13, claims Westport Insurance is obligated to pay more than the $5 million it has already agreed to under a 1998 policy. The city argues that policies issued in 1999, 2000, 2001, 2002 and 2003 included Public Entity Excess Law Enforcement Liability Coverage and Public Entity General Liability Coverage, which should cover claims arising from wrongful arrest, detention, malicious prosecution, and civil‑rights violations.
According to city Corporation Counsel Allison Jacobs, the insurer’s refusal to honor those later policies leaves New Haven shouldering the bulk of the settlement costs. “While the insurance company has agreed to extend a certain amount of coverage (approximately $5 million plus attorneys’ fees), the city believes it is owed additional coverage under our policy,” Jacobs said.
Financial impact on the city
The city has already borrowed $27 million from its aldermen to cover its share of the settlements, leaving the remaining $25.5 million to be funded from municipal resources. The lawsuit seeks monetary damages, pre‑judgment and post‑judgment interest, costs, and any other relief the court deems appropriate.
Broader context
This action follows other recent wrongful‑incarceration payouts in New Haven, including a $16.5 million settlement with Adam Carmon and a federal jury award of $38 million to Stefon Morant, which the city is currently appealing.
Westport Insurance could not be reached for comment at the time of publication.
Original reporting: New Haven Independent — read the source article.