Milford, Mich. – The owner of High Vibes Trail Rides, Lucie Ptasznik, has asked a court to order the return of 37 horses that were taken by Oakland County Animal Control earlier this summer. Ptasznik’s attorney, Todd Flood, filed a motion on behalf of his client, arguing that the seizure was based on a false, anonymous tip and that the animals were found in good health.
Background of the seizure
According to the motion, a former employee of the farm submitted an anonymous complaint alleging neglect. Animal Control responded, inspected the property and reported that the horses were well‑fed, had water, and appeared healthy. Two weeks after the inspection, a veterinarian examined the horses and confirmed they were in good condition, though a few required treatment for existing medical issues.
Allegations of procedural violations
Flood contends that on August 4, an Animal Control officer informed Ptasznik’s ex‑boyfriend that the horses would be taken, despite the officer having no legal authority to enter the property without permission. He asserts that the farm never received formal notice or a summons, violating the owner’s due‑process rights.
“Thirty‑seven horses worth over $300,000 in great shape were seized,” Flood said. “She lost a $200,000 contract because of this act. The anonymous caller had not been on the property since 2024. Law enforcement came out on July 16 and gave a clean bill of health. The sad part is someone’s due process was usurped by bogus information.”
Financial stakes
Oakland County has ordered High Vibes Trail Rides to pay $64,000 for the care and boarding of the horses while the investigation continues. If the fee is not paid, the county could forfeit the animals to the state.
High Vibes Trail Rides is a local business that offers guided trail rides to residents and visitors. The loss of the horses and the pending contract could have a significant impact on the farm’s operations and on the local tourism economy.
Legal next steps
The motion filed by Flood seeks an immediate court order for the horses’ return and a dismissal of the county’s care‑fee demand. The case will be heard in Oakland County Circuit Court, where the judge will consider whether proper legal procedures were followed and whether the seizure was justified.
Both parties have indicated they are prepared to present evidence, including the veterinarian’s report and the animal control inspection findings. The outcome will determine not only the fate of the 37 horses but also set a precedent for how county agencies handle anonymous complaints against private animal owners.
Community response
Local residents and fellow equine business owners have expressed concern over the incident, emphasizing the importance of protecting small businesses from what they view as overreach by government agencies. Many have highlighted the need for clear communication and proper legal process when animal welfare concerns arise.
The case underscores the delicate balance between ensuring animal welfare and respecting the property rights and due‑process protections afforded to Michigan’s citizens under the Constitution.
Original reporting: Warren | FOX 2 Detroit — read the source article.
