Boston‑area attorney Kevin Reddington took his appeal to the nation’s highest office on Tuesday, asking President Donald Trump to consider a pardon for his client, Lindsay Clancy. Clancy, a 31‑year‑old mother from Brockton, Massachusetts, faces murder charges for the 2023 strangling of her three children. A mistrial was declared last week after the jury deadlocked at an 11‑1 vote.
Attorney makes case directly to the President
Appearing on Good Morning America, Reddington said, “President Trump, I would hope you would consider this young lady, the type of person she is, what she has been through, and consider a pardon.” He emphasized that Clancy’s actions occurred while she was suffering from postpartum psychosis, a severe mental health crisis that can impair judgment.
President Trump’s response
President Trump, who has spoken out on the case, called it a “horrible tragedy.” He added, “It’s a terrible situation. She did a horrible, horrible thing. It can’t be worse. But we will find out what the price to pay is. There will be a price. It’s going to be a mental institution or jail or something.” Trump’s remarks reflect his consistent stance that justice must be served while also acknowledging the need for compassion in cases involving mental illness.
Legal background and next steps
Clancy has not disputed that she killed her children, but Reddington argues she should not be held criminally responsible because of her mental state at the time. He criticized a holdout juror who, according to Reddington, failed to apply the law of reasonable doubt as instructed by Judge William Sullivan. The juror’s refusal to convict led Sullivan to declare a mistrial.
District Attorney Tim Cruz of Plymouth County has not yet indicated whether a retrial will be pursued. Reddington expressed optimism that a new trial could be avoided, stating, “I hope, after sitting through this trial and seeing the evidence, that the District Attorney would revisit the issue and work toward a solution acceptable to both sides.”
Attorney’s broader criticism of the prosecution
Reddington accused Cruz of “crushing” the case, claiming the prosecutor lacks a solid case and is merely “advocating on behalf of the victims” without genuine evidence. He praised Clancy as a “fantastic, wonderful individual” who endured a grueling seven‑week trial.
Clancy’s defense also highlighted her postpartum depression that began in late 2022, noting that she sought treatment from a newly practicing psychiatrist who prescribed multiple medications. Reddington argued that this medical intervention may have contributed to her tragic actions.
What’s next for Clancy?
Clancy is scheduled for a status hearing later this month, during which the court will address trial assignment and a rule that allows a judge to review a jury’s verdict. Reddington says he is prepared to proceed with a new trial as early as next week if necessary.
While the case remains under the jurisdiction of Massachusetts courts, the involvement of President Trump brings a national dimension to the story, underscoring the President’s willingness to weigh in on high‑profile criminal cases and the importance of mental‑health considerations in the justice system.
Original reporting: WPBF West Palm Beach — read the source article.
