As the LSU Tigers get ready to open the 2026 season against Clemson, the conversation off the field is drawing as much attention as the matchup itself. Former LSU star pitcher and 1989 No. 1 MLB draft pick Ben McDonald appeared on Fox News’ “America Reports” to discuss the growing trend of former NFL, MLB and other professional athletes seeking a fifth year of college eligibility.
McDonald’s perspective
McDonald said he personally does not believe players should return to college after a professional stint, noting that most athletes have four years to compete before moving on. However, he acknowledged that the landscape has changed dramatically with the rise of name‑image‑likeness (NIL) deals and the financial incentives they provide.
“Once you’ve played your four years, it’s time to move on,” McDonald explained. “But with the NIL money out there, you can see why these kids want to come back. If you can’t make it in the NFL, MLB, wherever, maybe you have that opportunity to return for a fifth year of college and make some money.”
Coaches see a competitive edge
Top NFL agent Drew Rosenhaus echoed the sentiment, saying the “5‑for‑5” rule gives student‑athletes five years to play five seasons and that returning to college can be financially advantageous compared with an NFL practice‑squad salary.
LSU head coach Lane Kiffin, who recently took over the program, said his staff consulted a player leadership committee and reached a consensus to bring experienced former‑pros onto the roster if it helps the team win. “If I’m a head coach, I want those players,” Kiffin told reporters. “There is pressure to win now, and why not get the best players you can?”
Opposing views within the SEC
Not everyone in the conference agrees. Texas coach Steve Sarkisian criticized the practice, calling it morally wrong to pull a player off an NFL roster and force them back to college. He warned that such moves could disadvantage incoming freshmen who lack the same professional experience.
Meanwhile, a Louisiana judge is set to rule on a temporary restraining order that could prevent the SEC from penalizing schools that add former‑pros to their rosters. The decision could shape how the conference handles eligibility disputes for the rest of the season.
Impact on LSU’s freshman class
McDonald also voiced concern that the “5‑for‑5” rule may hurt LSU’s incoming freshman class, as returning players could limit opportunities for younger athletes to earn playing time.
As the Tigers prepare for their season opener, the debate over eligibility rules, NIL money, and competitive advantage will likely continue to influence recruiting strategies and roster decisions across the SEC.
Original reporting: Fox News (HLL/CB) — read the source article.
