Logan Square – The iconic “LOGAN” marquee above the historic Logan Theatre lit up again on Wednesday night, this time with bright white LED letters outlined in red. The original glass neon letters, which had adorned the theater for more than 75 years, were removed earlier this month for an energy‑efficiency upgrade.
Owner’s Rationale
Mark Fishman, the theater’s owner, explained that the new LED letters are part of a broader effort to improve maintenance and extend the lifespan of the building’s signage. “This important project guarantees easier maintenance and a longer life for the overall structure,” Fishman said in a statement to Block Club Chicago.
Community Reaction
The change has drawn mixed responses from local residents and preservation advocates. Andy Schneider, president of Logan Square Preservation and a local historian, noted that his group was informed of the removal but was not consulted about the conversion to LED. While he acknowledged that the sign remains visible, he stressed that the new lighting does not replicate the quality, intensity, or color of the original neon.
“The new LED will not achieve the same effect,” Schneider said. “The quality of the light matters, and the historic neon has a unique character that LED cannot fully replace.”
Preservation Perspective
Ward Miller, executive director of Preservation Chicago, praised the decision to keep the sign on the façade, noting that the LED upgrade eliminates safety hazards and reduces upkeep costs. “In an ideal world, a sign constructed out of neon is something that should be preserved,” Miller said, “but the owner is interested enough to restore this for the next 50‑70 years and is reinvesting in something iconic, even if the components are new.”
Kelsey McClellan, director of the Chicago Sign Museum, expressed disappointment that the original neon was not saved. She warned that Chicago is losing more historic signs as neon technicians become scarce and business owners lack awareness of preservation opportunities.
“Businesses are closing, and so the signs are coming down or many are disappearing,” McClellan said. “Repairing a few neon letters at a time is much more economical than replacing the entire sign with brand‑new letters, but it requires owners to be on board.”
Historical Context
The Logan Theatre opened in 1915 as the Paramount Theatre and has changed hands three times. Fishman purchased the venue in 2010, describing it as “his own private art project” and reopening it in 2012 after a major renovation that added new bathrooms, technology, and seating. Since then, the theater has continued to evolve with upgraded screens, an expanded lobby, and restored marble walls.
Looking Ahead
While the LED sign ensures the theater remains a visual landmark on Milwaukee Avenue, preservationists hope the original neon letters might be salvaged for display in a museum or community space. Schneider and McClellan’s groups continue to advocate for legislation that protects historic neon signage, especially as more storefronts with such signs shutter.
For now, the Logan Theatre’s bright new letters keep the neighborhood’s historic profile alive, even as the debate over preserving authentic neon versus embracing modern, low‑maintenance technology continues.
Original reporting: Block Club Chicago — read the source article.