In the November 3, 2026 election for Texas Court of Criminal Appeals, Place 3, Republican candidate Thomas Smith entered the statewide count with a 45,988‑vote lead over Democrat Okey Anyiam in the 253 counties outside Dallas County. However, the final Dallas County returns dramatically reversed that margin.
Dallas County Results
The Dallas County Elections Department’s November 10 report, included in the November 17 Commissioners Court canvass packet, shows 517,350 votes for Anyiam, 233,531 for Smith and 19,703 for Libertarian Mark Ash. Although labeled “Unofficial Results,” the packet recommends certification by the commissioners, making these figures the most current accounting of the county’s vote.
Smith’s own analysis, posted on November 17, cited an earlier statewide tracker that listed 516,583 votes for Anyiam and 233,243 for Smith in Dallas County – a 283,340‑vote margin. The later packet’s totals explain the slight discrepancy, but the overall impact remains the same: a Democratic advantage of roughly 283,000 votes in Dallas County erased Smith’s lead elsewhere.
Implications for the GOP
Smith wrote, “The GOP cannot survive without being competitive in urban counties, in Texas or anywhere else. It’s unsustainable. This is not a criticism of the current local party leadership. They’re working hard and trying. But this has to improve.” He also recalled a time when Dallas County was reliably red, suggesting that the county’s shift has broader consequences for Republican prospects statewide.
While Smith claimed he could have lost Dallas County by 7 % and still won statewide, the numbers do not support that precise threshold. Seven percent of the 770,584 ballots cast for the three candidates in the county’s later report equals about 53,941 votes, exceeding Smith’s 45,988‑vote lead outside Dallas County. In other words, a defeat of roughly 6 % in Dallas would still have left Smith ahead, but a larger loss, as the final results show, flipped the race.
Historical Context
The pattern mirrors previous elections. In the 2024 U.S. Senate race, Democrat Colin Allred captured 63.01 % of Dallas County votes, beating Republican Ted Cruz by 28.43 points. In the 2026 Senate contest, Democrat James Talarico won 71.72 % of the county’s vote, while Republican Ken Paxton earned 26.27 %, a margin 17 points larger than Allred’s 2024 win. These figures illustrate how Dallas County’s Democratic lean can outweigh Republican strength elsewhere in Texas.
Local Party Efforts
The Dallas County Republican Party advertised phone and text banking ahead of Election Day, but the notice did not provide verified totals for contacts, door knocks, or money raised. Election returns alone cannot determine which campaign tactics altered the outcome.
Smith’s analysis underscores a broader strategic challenge for Texas Republicans: maintaining competitiveness in the state’s largest urban centers while preserving strength in rural and suburban areas. As Dallas County continues to deliver decisive Democratic margins, GOP candidates will need to adapt their outreach and messaging to address the concerns of urban voters.
Looking Ahead
For voters and candidates alike, the Dallas County results serve as a reminder that statewide victories in Texas increasingly depend on performance in the state’s major metropolitan counties. The Republican Party’s ability to reconnect with urban constituents may prove pivotal in upcoming races for judicial, legislative, and executive offices.
Original reporting: The Dallas Express — read the source article.