Mobile County Circuit Court Judge Michael Windom intervened Wednesday in the murder trial of 25‑year‑old Reuben Thomas Gulley, accused of fatally shooting Randon Lee during a 2022 drug deal in Prichard. The judge instructed defense attorney Chase Dearman to stop pressing a witness about the prior perjury conviction of former Detective Jason Hadaway.
Background of the case
Gulley, a resident of Saraland, faces murder charges after Lee was shot in the left shoulder, with the bullet piercing both lungs and a blood vessel near the aorta. A medical examiner testified that Lee died within minutes of the wound. Prosecutors allege Gulley retrieved a gun from Lee’s vehicle and fired during the altercation.
Witness testimony and the dispute
During cross‑examination, Detective Sergeant Bart Andrews recounted that after the Lee shooting, the Prichard Police Department removed Detective Jason Hadaway from investigations. When Dearman asked why, the prosecution objected and Judge Windom instructed Andrews not to answer. Dearman argued the record needed to be preserved for appeal, but the judge warned him to keep his voice down so jurors, who had been sent outside the courtroom, would not hear the discussion.
“Whatever his removal was for, it had nothing to do with this case,” Judge Windom said, emphasizing that the prior conviction should not influence the current trial.
Prior perjury conviction
Hadaway was found guilty last year of lying under oath during a probation revocation hearing. The defense sought to introduce that conviction to challenge the credibility of the police investigation, but the judge ruled the matter irrelevant to the murder charge.
Details of the shooting
Andrews testified that surveillance video from the Pride gas station on St. Stephens Road showed a black car parked and a silver vehicle pulling up. A man in a red hoodie—identified by prosecutors as Gulley—exited the silver car, entered the black car, then returned to the silver vehicle and drove away, holding a gun. “It was less than 30 seconds,” Andrews said.
Andrews also confirmed he did not see any firearms in Lee’s car and that standard police procedure calls for photographing and properly collecting all evidence. He agreed with Dearman that every investigative step should be documented and that interviews with witnesses should be recorded.
Defense’s focus on investigative conduct
Dearman has repeatedly questioned the thoroughness of the Prichard police investigation, asking why two interviews with Lee’s girlfriend were not recorded. Andrews replied, “I wasn’t present for any of those, Mr. Dearman, I can’t answer that.” The defense continues to argue that procedural lapses may have compromised the case.
Next steps
Testimony is set to resume Thursday, with the prosecution expected to call additional witnesses and present forensic evidence. The judge’s decision to exclude discussion of Hadaway’s perjury conviction underscores the court’s focus on the facts directly related to the murder charge.
Original reporting: FOX10 WALA Mobile (news) — read the source article.