Jonesboro, Ark. – Presley Phillips Noel, a former deputy prosecutor for the Second Judicial District, filed a federal lawsuit on Oct. 14 alleging she was terminated on Jan. 9, 2026, just one day after submitting maternity‑leave paperwork to the state.
Allegations of Discriminatory Treatment
Noel contends that she informed Chief Deputy Prosecutor Jessica Thomason of her pregnancy and asked that the information remain confidential. According to the complaint, Thomason disclosed the news to Prosecuting Attorney Sonia Hagood, after which Noel was fired. The suit claims the termination violated the Family and Medical Leave Act, Title VII, the Pregnancy Discrimination Act, the Pregnant Workers Fairness Act, and the 14th Amendment’s equal‑protection guarantee.
Employment Record and Leave Request
Noel began working for the district in January 2023 and says she logged more than 1,250 hours in the year preceding her termination, meeting the statutory requirements for leave. She submitted her maternity‑leave request on Jan. 8, 2026, and was dismissed the following day, despite being due to give birth in March.
Performance Evaluation Dispute
The defendants cited a May 15, 2025 performance evaluation that rated Noel 2 out of 5 in several categories, including customer service and job knowledge. Noel disputes the evaluation’s existence, asserting it was fabricated after she filed an EEOC charge and that she only ever received a satisfactory review after her initial 90‑day period. She also says she was never counseled, warned, written up, or suspended for the alleged deficiencies.
Workload and Transfer Concerns
In April 2025, Noel was transferred to Mississippi County to lead the Drug Task Force docket while retaining the Craighead County juvenile docket. She alleges the move increased her workload from two to six dockets, added more than two hours of daily travel, and left her without an office, forcing her to cover personal expenses.
Legal Claims and Relief Sought
The complaint seeks damages exceeding $75,000, back pay, front pay or reinstatement, compensation for physical and emotional suffering, liquidated damages for wage loss, punitive damages, attorney fees, and costs. Noel also requests a positive reference, clearance of her personnel file, training for the defendants, an apology, public posting of the lawsuit and any verdict, and a jury trial.
Judicial Status
U.S. District Judge James M. Moody Jr. recused himself on Oct. 16 after discovering that Noel’s attorney, Luther Sutter, appears on his recusal list. The case has been randomly reassigned, and the defendants have not filed a response as of Nov. 19, 2026.
Community Impact
The lawsuit highlights concerns about how local government agencies handle pregnancy‑related leave and underscores the importance of protecting family and medical rights for public‑sector employees in Arkansas.
Original reporting: NEA Report (Jonesboro) — read the source article.