St. Petersburg’s downtown music landmark, Jannus Live, faces an uncertain future as its owner, Jeffry Knight, searches for an investor to finance a major renovation while legal battles swirl around the property.
Venue’s standing and ownership
Knight, a 64‑year‑old independent promoter, says Jannus Live is among the nation’s top five 2,000‑seat music venues, a status it has held for the past decade. The venue operates out of the historic Peacock Building—now known as the Jannus Landing Retail Building—located at the corner of 2nd Street and 1st Avenue N. Knight owns the building and the surrounding 11,000‑square‑foot courtyard, which has hosted standing‑room‑only concerts since the mid‑1980s.
The courtyard, however, is owned by real‑estate developer Tony Amico under the entity St. Pete Jannus LLC. Amico claims an option agreement signed in 2015 gives him a right of first refusal on the Peacock Building if it is placed on the market. Knight disputes that the agreement ever granted exclusive rights.
Legal conflict
Amico is suing Knight for alleged breach of the option agreement, demanding a “fair market price” for the building. Knight counters that the contract never gave Amico exclusive purchase rights and that Amico reneged on a verbal offer to sell the courtyard last year, despite Knight paying over $40,000 a month in rent for that space.
Complicating matters, a pending civil suit alleges Knight backed out of a 2025 deal to sell the building to Hall Productions for $8.5 million. Knight is asking $11.5 million for the property and has outlined an ambitious “Jannus Live Music Factory” concept that would add a three‑story rooftop patio, a dueling‑piano bar, a gourmet buffet restaurant and other amenities.
Investor search and renovation plan
Knight says any buyer would need to invest an additional $3 million to realize the Music Factory vision. He already holds the liquor license, sound and lighting equipment, and a master lease on the building, which includes operating businesses such as Dalmoros, Sheso Crispy and Joey Brooklyn’s Famous Pizza Kitchen, as well as the second‑floor Landing Bar.
He emphasizes that the venue’s essential infrastructure—stage, sound system, and 27 women’s restrooms—lies within his property and would move with any new owner. The easements that provide ingress and egress to the courtyard are described as perpetual, meaning a reduced restroom count could lower the venue’s allowable capacity.
Potential short‑term lease extension
Amico’s management contract expires at the end of December, leaving about 60 already‑booked shows at risk. A “Short‑Term Lease Sheet” sent by St. Pete Jannus, LLC outlines conditions for a six‑month extension, including termination of a 1995 easement, a 10‑year right to use a VIP entrance, and exclusive rights to the “Jannus Landing” name.
Both parties acknowledge that the courtyard could continue operating under a revised agreement, but Knight argues that the Music Factory would keep the space active year‑round, offsetting the venue’s seasonal downtime.
Legal proceedings and personal impact
In February, Knight will face a trial in Pinellas Circuit Court on 24 charges stemming from a 2025 incident in which his 37‑foot boat collided with the Clearwater Ferry, resulting in one passenger death. Knight, on his attorney’s advice, has limited public comment, describing the accident as “horrible” and an “accident” that he lives with daily.
The outcome of both the civil and criminal cases, along with the pending real‑estate dispute, will shape the future of Jannus Live—a venue that has been a cultural mainstay for Tampa Bay music lovers for nearly three decades.
Original reporting: St. Pete Catalyst — read the source article.