Marion County, Fla. – A trial began this week in the Marion County Circuit Court for Dwight Hall, 54, accused of kidnapping and murdering Sonia Exelby, a 32‑year‑old music tutor from southern England. Prosecutors say Hall met Exelby on the now‑defunct adult website Motherless.com, where she was seeking companionship after a history of severe depression and suicidal thoughts.
Alleged grooming and travel
According to the prosecution, Hall, who used the alias “Alpha Sadist” on the site, groomed Exelby for roughly two years. In October 2025, Exelby traveled to the United States, arriving at Gainesville Regional Airport. Hall allegedly picked her up and drove her to an Airbnb where the alleged crime took place.
Prosecution’s case
Florida assistant state attorney Amy Berndt told jurors that Exelby “was always trying to find some substitute” for self‑harm and that she believed men on Motherless would help her die. Berndt quoted a message from the prosecution: “Unfortunately, there was no shortage of depraved men willing to kill Sonia in the most torturous and vile ways possible.”
Prosecutors presented a text allegedly sent by Exelby to a friend, in which she expressed fear that Hall would force her to shoot him and that she saw no way out. They also showed video from Hall’s phone in which he demanded Exelby repeat that she wanted to be beaten and suffer.
Physical evidence includes a shovel and a knife with Exelby’s blood, as confirmed by DNA testing. Investigators also recovered images on Hall’s phone depicting other women being raped, tortured and murdered.
Defense response
Hall has pleaded not guilty to first‑degree murder and kidnapping. His defense team argues that Hall was attempting to help a woman who wanted to die, and that the evidence does not prove he caused her death. Hall told police he had been intimate with Exelby, but denied any involvement in her killing.
Victim’s background
Exelby’s sister, Sara, testified that her sibling struggled with mental illness, severe depression and suicidal ideation, but was also “always supportive and kind.” Sara described her sister as a “beautiful” person who felt she was a burden, despite not being one.
Discovery of the body
Exelby’s body was found on October 17, 2025, after Interpol alerted U.S. authorities to a missing‑person report from Britain. Police recovered her remains from a shallow grave, noting four stab wounds and extensive bruising.
Broader context
The case highlights ongoing concerns about technology‑facilitated violence against women. Motherless.com, the platform at the center of the alleged grooming, was taken offline in May 2026 by Dutch authorities following a CNN investigation into online drug‑facilitated sexual assault. In July, Texas Attorney General Ken Paxton secured a court order cutting off the site’s ability to operate under the .com registry.
The trial is expected to last at least a week, during which jurors will consider the digital, physical and testimonial evidence presented by both sides.
Original reporting: KRDO (Colorado Springs metro) — read the source article.