Atlantic Beach, Fla. – The race for Seat 4 on the Atlantic Beach City Commission was settled in an unusual way last week. After a manual and machine recount confirmed that candidates Jennifer Lagner and Lisa Herrold each received exactly 3,162 votes, Duval County Supervisor of Elections Jerry Holland invoked the city’s tiebreaker rule.
Coin‑toss tiebreaker
Under Atlantic Beach election guidelines, a tied race is resolved by a series of up to three coin flips, with each candidate calling the outcome of each toss. Herrold went first, calling heads, but the coin landed tails, giving Lagner a 1‑0 lead. Lagner then called heads on the second flip, and the coin landed heads, securing her victory.
“This shows how great and free our country is,” Lagner told a local news outlet. “I am honored to have the opportunity to serve as your next City Commissioner for Seat 4. A coin toss was certainly an unexpected and unforgettable way to bring an election to a close!” She added a thank‑you to Supervisor Holland and his team for their work throughout the process.
Reactions from the candidates
Herrold, while disappointed, remained gracious. “Jen and I have been a part of this community for years … It was meant to be … We’ll look back at this and realize how unbelievable this was,” she said to the local outlet.
Supervisor Holland emphasized the broader lesson of the tie. “It’s remarkable, really … the meaning of that is every vote matters, you know, and one vote can make a difference,” he remarked.
Historical context
This is not the first time Duval County has used an unconventional method to break an electoral tie. In the 2014 Neptune Beach City Council race, candidates resolved a deadlock by drawing numbered ping‑pong balls, with the higher number winning.
Atlantic Beach voters can now look forward to a new commissioner who will join the city council’s efforts on local issues such as public safety, zoning, and community development. Lagner’s victory, though decided by chance, underscores the critical role of every single ballot in shaping local governance.
What’s next for the commission
Commissioner‑elect Lagner will be sworn in at the next council meeting, where she will begin work on the city’s 2027 budget, upcoming zoning revisions, and initiatives aimed at preserving the coastal character of Atlantic Beach. Residents are encouraged to stay engaged with council meetings and upcoming community forums.
Original reporting: Fox News (HLL/CB) — read the source article.