After months of negotiations, the former St. Francis de Sales Catholic church on the former Martin University campus will not be demolished. The building, constructed in 1913, has been granted historic status by the Indianapolis Historic Preservation Commission, putting demolition on hold while the city and the property’s owner, Eastern Star Church, work out a preservation plan.
Sale announced as preservation option
Trena Roudebush, spokesperson for the Department of Metropolitan Development, told Mirror Indy that Eastern Star Church and the city have reached an agreement that the historic church will be preserved. Eastern Star is now planning to sell the building, and its attorney, Howard Stevenson, confirmed that a prospective buyer has expressed interest, though the buyer’s identity was not disclosed.
Background on the property
Martin University, the only predominantly Black university in Indianapolis, closed at the end of 2025. Eastern Star Church purchased the former campus in May and renamed it the ROCK Impact Center, expanding its existing Renewing Our Community for the Kingdom Initiative. The church’s acquisition was initially intended to support community development, but a contractor later filed a wrecking permit to demolish the historic church in August. The historic designation halted that effort, though final approval still rests with the Metropolitan Development Commission.
Historic significance and community response
St. Francis de Sales Catholic Church was founded in 1881, and the current building has served eastside families for over a century. The attached Catholic school closed in 1983 after declining enrollment, a trend attributed to the construction of the I‑70 interstate, according to the Archdiocese of Indianapolis.
Indiana Landmarks has long monitored the campus for preservation. André Myers, director of the organization’s Black Heritage Preservation Program, said the property’s sale presents an opportunity to retain a “viable and vibrant” historic asset for the surrounding community. Earlier this year, Indiana Landmarks awarded a $25,000 grant to assess the building’s condition. The assessment found the structure solid, though in need of routine maintenance.
Church leadership’s perspective
Pastor Anthony Murdock, who leads the ROCK Initiative at Eastern Star Church, acknowledged that the congregation did not anticipate the historic designation when they purchased the property. “We just don’t have experience developing historic spaces,” Murdock said, adding that the church is “open to those discussions” about selling the building to parties better equipped to preserve it.
The Metropolitan Development Commission was scheduled to vote on a historic area plan for the property on Nov. 18, but the city and Eastern Star requested a postponement until Jan. 6, 2027, to allow more time for the sale process and preservation planning.
What’s next?
The city’s historic preservation officials will continue to review the sale and any future development proposals to ensure the building’s architectural integrity is maintained. Community members and preservation advocates are watching closely, hoping the eventual buyer will honor the building’s legacy while contributing to the revitalization of Indianapolis’ eastside neighborhoods.
Mirror Indy, a nonprofit newsroom, is funded through grants and donations from individuals, foundations, and organizations.
Original reporting: Mirror Indy — read the source article.