Denver residents will be watching a new investigation into city government transparency after the District Attorney’s Office announced Friday it will take an “initial look” at claims that the City Attorney’s Office improperly withheld a public record. The record in question is a letter dated August 24, 2015 that rescinded the termination of senior city attorney Stuart Shapiro, who had been placed on paid leave in July 2014 amid suspicions of mishandling a high‑profile case.
According to CBS4, City Attorney Scott Martinez sent Shapiro a termination notice on August 11, 2015, but then, two weeks later, issued a second letter rescinding that termination. The rescission letter was mailed to Shapiro’s home address in Denver, signed by Litigation Director Rob Nespor, and copied to several city departments. When CBS4 filed a Colorado Open Records Act request on August 28 for a copy of that letter, City Attorney staff responded that no such document existed.
Six months later, CBS4 obtained the very letter the City Attorney’s office claimed never existed. Attorney Steve Zansberg called the city’s denial “an outright lie” and said the case is “as open and shut or black and white” as he has seen. Martinez, in an on‑camera interview, maintained that his office acted truthfully and that the letter was removed from Shapiro’s personnel file during ongoing negotiations with Shapiro and his lawyer.
Colorado’s Open Records Act makes willful withholding of public records a misdemeanor, and the law requires agencies to identify the custodian of any requested records. The City Attorney’s office did not provide a custodian’s name or address, instead asserting the letter never existed. Martinez declined to answer whether the document had been destroyed.
Shapiro, who now works from home, filed a whistleblower claim alleging he was disciplined for reporting misconduct by his supervisors. A hearing on that claim is scheduled for May. The District Attorney’s Office has not set a timeline for completing its review.
What’s next: The DA’s review will determine whether the City Attorney’s Office violated the Open Records Act. Meanwhile, Shapiro’s whistleblower hearing in May will address his allegations of retaliation. Denver residents can expect further updates as the investigation proceeds.
Sources: cbsnews.com