The Birmingham Design Review Committee voted Wednesday morning to approve demolition of six historic structures across three neighborhoods, a decision that could reshape parts of Midtown, Highland Park and the Hanover Place Historic District.
In Midtown, the committee cleared Alabama Power’s request to raze a vacant building at 1930 Powell Ave. adjacent to the utility’s substation. The utility plans to replace the structure with a brick‑infilled concrete wall surrounding the lot to deter trespassing and vagrancy, an issue the company has faced at the site.
Committee members expressed mixed reactions to the wall design. Environmental specialist James Douglas presented renderings of a flush concrete wall with Flemish diagonal‑bond brick infill, noting the need for a smooth surface to prevent scaling. Cheryl Morgan, who voted against demolition, criticized the lack of visual relief, saying, “So, what makes visual interest in almost every other example is the contrast…” She also lamented that the applicant had not considered reusing the building at a key 20th‑Street gateway to the Parkside and Downtown districts.
In Highland Park, the committee approved demolition of three structures located at 1054 24th St. S., 2130 Highland Ave. and 2312 Highland Ave.. While the demolition was approved, the committee did not grant approval for new apartments or site‑preparation work at this time.
Separately, the committee unanimously approved FiveStone Group LLC’s request—on behalf of Sterling Capital IV LLC and Southside Investors II LLC—to demolish three U‑shaped apartment buildings in the southwestern edge of the Hanover Place Historic District. The buildings, formerly known as the Baycourt, Phares and Caldwell Parc, were constructed in the late 1920s and are classified as contributing structures to the district.
According to FiveStone associate David Silverstein Jr., a licensed structural engineer’s assessment dated Sept. 15 documented overstressed wood framing, rotting joists and foundation settlement, concluding that repair would be cost‑prohibitive. Chief engineer J. Stuart Lee of Structural Design Group refused to enter the buildings because of safety hazards. Silverstein emphasized that the buildings have been vacant since September of last year and pose a risk to the community, especially homeless individuals seeking shelter.
The new conceptual plan from KPS Group envisions a 1.128‑acre site with two commercial apartment buildings totaling 90 units, rising 32 feet from the alley. The three former apartments contained 43 units before vacancy.
Committee members weighed the tension between preserving historic character and addressing safety and public‑order concerns. Morgan noted, “I don’t want to regret it because we’ve devalued the integrity of the entire neighborhood,” while also acknowledging the need to prevent further deterioration and potential hazards.
What’s next: The demolition approvals are for the structures only; final design plans for the wall at Powell Ave. and the new apartment development in Hanover Place have not been approved. The committee will continue to review conceptual designs and any additional permits required before construction can begin.
Sources: birminghamwatch.org