Little Rock, Ark. – Attorney Matthew Draper says he was a victim of alleged misconduct by Nancie Givens, the former executive director of the Arkansas Supreme Court’s Office of Professional Programs. Givens was arrested earlier this month on 65 felony counts for allegedly tampering with bar exam scores between 2020 and 2025.
Repeated obstacles on exam applications
Draper, who attempted the Arkansas bar exam eight times over eight years, says Givens repeatedly found fault with his application paperwork, demanding resubmissions and charging additional fees. “Every time I turned something in, this lady’s email would say something was missing,” he told KATV. “I’d send it again, and she would find something else wrong.”
Unusual acknowledgment form
When finally allowed to sit for the exam, Draper says Givens required him to sign a special acknowledgment stating that even if he passed, admission to the bar was not guaranteed and his name would not appear on the public list of successful examinees. Instead, Givens would personally email him his result.
“I had to sign one of these every time I took the bar exam all the way up until 2020,” Draper recalled. He never received a direct score report. “The emails she would send me would tell me I didn’t pass. She’d say my scores were in the mail, but I never actually received them,” he added.
Impact on family and career
The repeated setbacks, combined with the pressure of providing for his growing family, left Draper questioning his future in law. “When your wife’s got a kid on the way, you feel the urgency to succeed,” he said. “I was doubting myself every time.” After Givens’ arrest, Draper said he felt a sense of vindication, noting that his gut had long suspected something was amiss.
Calls for systemic reform
Draper argues that the alleged misconduct points to a lack of checks and balances within the Supreme Court’s Office of Professional Programs and the State Board of Law Examiners. “If one person could do this for so long, it shows a failure in oversight,” he said. He is considering filing a civil lawsuit against Givens and plans to share his experience with prosecutors.
Legal proceedings continue
Givens faces a massive felony indictment covering alleged score manipulation that may have caused some candidates to fail unjustly while allowing others who should have failed to pass. The case remains under investigation, and state officials have not commented on potential reforms to the bar exam administration process.
The Arkansas legal community is watching closely, as the outcome could reshape how bar exam scores are handled and increase transparency for future examinees.
Original reporting: KATV Little Rock (local) — read the source article.