The Legislative Audit Bureau (LAB) released a 146‑page audit on Friday that examined Wisconsin’s public, charter and private school report cards for the 2022‑2025 school years. The independent review, commissioned by the Republican‑led Joint Legislative Audit Committee, concluded that the current report‑card system falls short of the statutory requirement to give families clear performance information.
Key findings and recommendations
LAB identified thirteen specific recommendations for the Department of Public Instruction (DPI). Among them are calls for written policies on testing changes, broader stakeholder feedback, and a clearer methodology that balances achievement, growth, target‑group outcomes and on‑track‑to‑graduation metrics. The bureau also asked DPI to report back to the audit committee by March 30, 2027 on progress toward these changes.
According to the audit, the percentage of schools meeting, exceeding, or significantly exceeding expectations rose between the 2022‑2023 and 2024‑2025 school years. Likewise, the share of schools falling short of expectations declined during the same period. While most districts saw no change in their overall performance category from 2023‑2024 to 2024‑2025, about one‑fifth of schools and districts moved up one category, indicating some improvement.
Political response
State Senator Eric Wimberger (R‑Gillett) and Representative Robert Wittke (R‑Caledonia), chairs of the audit committee, called the current report cards “an untrustworthy sham” and urged DPI to put Wisconsin students, families and schools ahead of politics and bureaucracy.
State Superintendent Jill Underly pushed back, describing the audit as “notable” only because it arrived the same week district report cards were issued after months of silence from LAB. She emphasized DPI’s transparency, participation in public hearings and the department’s belief that the audit contains “factually incorrect assertions” and oversteps its scope.
Methodology concerns
The audit notes that DPI places greater weight on student achievement and growth than on raw performance scores, a weighting scheme approved by the GOP‑controlled legislature and signed into law by former Governor Scott Walker. Critics argue this makes it difficult for parents to compare districts directly.
In 2021, a bill proposing equal weight for all four priority areas was vetoed by Governor Tony Evers, who warned that the legislature was “politicizing our schools.” The veto underscores the ongoing partisan debate over how best to measure school quality.
What’s next?
LAB’s recommendations aim to strengthen accountability and ensure that families receive meaningful data. The audit also highlighted a lack of documented stakeholder feedback on testing changes, urging DPI to improve its outreach and record‑keeping.
As Wisconsin’s education leaders consider these findings, the state’s schools continue to show modest gains in performance metrics, offering a hopeful sign that reforms could further elevate student outcomes.
Original reporting: Wisconsin Watch — read the source article.