Thyme & Season Natural Market has been on Whalley Avenue since 1974 — which means it predates most of the natural food chains that eventually swallowed up stores just like it everywhere else. It never got swallowed.
Donna Curran has worked the floor there longer than she can easily calculate. She started part-time in the mid-1980s, planning to leave when something better came along, and somewhere in that stretch the job became a life’s work. She knows where everything is without looking. She knows which protein powders are worth the price and which ones she quietly steers people away from. When a regular comes in asking about a supplement their doctor mentioned, she pulls up a stool and talks it through.
“I’m not a pharmacist,” she says, carefully. “But I’ve been doing this a long time. I try to actually be helpful.”
That’s the operating principle of the whole store, as far as I can tell. Thyme & Season is not a big-box natural grocer. It’s maybe 2,500 square feet, the aisles are narrow, and the layout would confuse a stranger. But it carries an impressive range of things you’d otherwise have to order online: bulk herbs and spices by the ounce, local raw honey, a rotating selection of Vermont and Connecticut cheeses, cold-pressed juices made in-house most mornings, and a deli counter that does a genuinely good egg salad on whole grain.
The supplement wall is what a lot of people come for. It’s floor-to-ceiling and organized with more logic than it appears at first glance. Donna can walk you through the difference between magnesium glycinate and magnesium oxide in about forty-five seconds, if you ask. She won’t push you toward the more expensive one just because it’s more expensive.
The store sits in Westville, technically, though it hugs the line between that neighborhood and the Whalley commercial strip closer to Amity. Parking on the street is usually available. The store is open seven days, closing around seven most evenings. Prices on grocery staples are fair — occasionally cheaper than the chains on certain things, occasionally a few cents more. The deli items run between six and ten dollars.
What it offers that the chains can’t is the conversation. Not the scripted wellness-counter chat you get at a big natural grocery, where the employee is reading from the same training materials the company sent to forty other locations. Donna’s opinions are her own, built from decades of watching what actually seems to help people and what doesn’t. She remembers customers’ names. She asks follow-up questions when someone comes back.
The store has survived long enough to watch its own neighborhood change substantially around it. New restaurants opened. Old ones closed. Yale’s footprint expanded. Whalley Avenue had its rough years and its better years. Through most of it, Thyme & Season just kept restocking the bulk herbs and making the egg salad.
“We’re not trying to be anything we’re not,” Donna told me, wiping down the deli counter on a slow Thursday afternoon. “People need a place like this. So we stay.”
It’s on Whalley near West Rock Avenue. Worth the stop if you’re in Westville for any reason, or if you need someone who actually knows what they’re talking about to help you figure out a supplement question.