District Court Judge Peter Froelicher on Nov. 6 refused to dismiss the lawsuit challenging Wyoming’s universal school‑choice program, allowing the case to proceed toward trial. The decision keeps the future of the Steamboat Legacy Scholarship Program in doubt as enrolled families continue to receive up to $7,000 per student for private‑school expenses.
Program details and legal challenge
The 2025 law, known as the Steamboat Legacy Scholarship Act, lets Wyoming residents apply for state funds to cover tuition, admission fees to zoos, internet classes for homeschooling children and other K‑12 private‑school costs. The program is income‑qualified, providing the benefit only to families earning at or below 250% of the federal poverty level – roughly $80,000 for a family of four.
Shortly after the law’s passage, a group of parents and the Wyoming Education Association (WEA) sued to halt the program, arguing it violates the Wyoming Constitution, which bars public funds from being given to individuals or private entities except for “necessary support of the poor.” The complaint named Superintendent of Public Instruction Megan Degenfelder, State Treasurer Curt Meier and the State of Wyoming as defendants.
Judge’s ruling and next steps
Defendants moved to dismiss the case on the ground that the plaintiffs lacked standing. Judge Froelicher rejected that argument, stating he will continue to evaluate whether the scholarship program aligns with constitutional mandates that require the Legislature to fund public education and prohibit the use of public money for private and parochial schools.
The Wyoming Education Association welcomed the ruling. Association President Kimberly Amen said the decision “allows the case to move forward toward trial” and reaffirmed the WEA’s belief that “public dollars belong in public schools.”
Supporters cite prior court rulings
School‑choice advocates, including families who intervened on behalf of the state, point to a May decision by the Wyoming Supreme Court that reversed a 2025 injunction against the program’s rollout. EdChoice Director of Litigation Thomas M. Fisher noted that the Supreme Court held the educational savings account program does not affect the public‑school funding model and that plaintiffs cannot claim an educational injury from a program they do not intend to use.
Fisher added that the district court’s denial of the motion for judgment on the pleadings “will not change the governing law in this case,” emphasizing that the legal battle will focus on the merits rather than procedural dismissal.
Political context and public reaction
The scholarship program represents a significant expansion of school choice in a state where the Legislature is controlled by Republicans. Lawmakers debated the measure’s constitutionality during the 2025 session, with Rep. Ocean Andrew (R‑Laramie) advocating for a broader voucher program after criticizing an earlier, narrower 2024 version.
Critics argue the program could divert funds from public schools, reducing enrollment and consequently shrinking the state’s education budget. Supporters counter that the income‑qualified design safeguards constitutional concerns while giving families flexibility to tailor education to their children’s needs.
Current status of applications
After the Supreme Court’s May reversal, the state reopened applications for the 2025‑26 school year. Thousands of families submitted requests for tuition, tutoring, online classes and other educational expenses. Intervening defendant Nikki Leck told WyoFile the program provides “flexibility to tailor education to their children’s specific needs.”
The legal dispute remains unresolved, and Judge Froelicher’s decision ensures that both sides will have the opportunity to present evidence and arguments before a final ruling is issued.
What’s at stake
At its core, the case tests the balance between parental choice, constitutional limits on state spending, and the preservation of a robust public‑education system. The outcome will likely shape how Wyoming and other states approach voucher and scholarship programs in the coming years.
Original reporting: Oil City News (Casper WY) — read the source article.