If you’ve never been to a Wisconsin supper club before, here’s the question everyone asks: is it actually a club, and do I have to join? The answer is no, obviously, but Jaime’s Restaurant & Cocktail Lounge on South Oneida Street is about as good a place as any to learn what the term actually means — slow evening, strong drink, relish tray, and a cut of beef that earns its price.
Jaime’s has been operating on the south end of Appleton since 1976, which in restaurant years is essentially geological time. The building sits in a commercial strip that doesn’t advertise itself as a destination, and that’s part of the point. You don’t stumble into Jaime’s. You plan to go. You make a reservation, or you show up on a Tuesday when it’s quieter, and you settle in for the kind of dinner that takes two hours because that’s the right amount of time for dinner to take.
The room has the dark-wood, low-light atmosphere that the supper club format demands — high-backed booths, a full bar visible from most tables, an ease about the whole thing that feels earned rather than designed. The cocktail lounge at the front does real work here. The old-fashioned comes with a brandy base as a matter of course, the way Wisconsin intended it, and nobody is rushing you out of it before your table’s ready.
What to order? I’d tell you to start with the relish tray and the shrimp cocktail, eat the crackers, don’t skip the soup. The prime rib is the main event on weekends — slow-roasted, served with au jus, available in cuts ranging from sensible to deeply ambitious. I went with the queen cut on a Friday night and had no complaints. The filet mignon and the lobster tail are on the menu if you’re celebrating something. Prices run from the mid-twenties for some entrees into the forties and above for the prime rib and surf options, which is consistent with what you’d expect from a place that hasn’t cut corners in forty-plus years.
Service is attentive without being performative. The staff know the menu, they don’t hover, and they’ve clearly been around long enough that the room runs on its own rhythm. That rhythm is unhurried. If you’re in a rush, eat somewhere else. If you have the whole evening and someone worth sharing it with, Jaime’s is a genuinely good use of a Friday.
The clientele skews toward people who’ve been coming here since before you were born and younger couples who figured out that a real supper club beats a trendy spot nine times out of ten. Both groups are correct. There’s a reason places like this survive while flashier restaurants cycle through.
Jaime’s is at 601 S. Oneida Street on Appleton’s south side. They’re open Tuesday through Saturday for dinner. Reservations are worth making on weekends. Dress however you like, but the room has a certain formality to it — you’ll probably want to match it a little.