CHARLESTON, West Virginia – In a Friday afternoon opinion, the West Virginia Supreme Court rejected a legal challenge brought by State Democratic Party Chairman Mike Pushkin and activist Stephen Willingham. The petition sought to force House Speaker Roger Hanshaw and Governor Patrick Morrisey to appoint a Democrat to the vacant District 91 seat in the House of Delegates.
Background of the vacancy
Republican Ian Masters was appointed to fill the seat after former delegate Joseph de Soto was arrested in February 2025 and charged with threatening to harm or kill Republican lawmakers. De Soto, originally elected as a Republican in November 2024, switched to the Democratic Party shortly before his arrest. The House passed a resolution on Jan. 8, 2025, vacating his seat on the grounds that his home confinement and two protective orders would prevent him from taking the oath of office in the Capitol.
Court’s reasoning
Chief Justice Haley Bunn wrote that the court cannot order Speaker Hanshaw to seat de Soto, nor can it compel Governor Morrisey to request a list of Democratic nominees from the Berkeley County Democratic Party. The petitioners lacked “redressability,” meaning the court has no authority to grant the relief they seek. Bunn noted that the Democrats filed three separate writs, with the third—filed in September 2025—being the one before the court.
“We find that, under the circumstances of this case, this Court cannot order either Respondent to carry out these actions, and accordingly, the Petitioners’ purported injury is not redressable,” Bunn wrote.
Impact of recent legislation
Since Masters’ appointment, state law has changed. Senate Bill 586, passed last year, requires that vacancies for state officials, judges, and magistrates be filled by a nominee from the same party that originally held the seat at the time of election. The law does not apply retroactively to the de Soto vacancy, which was created after his party switch.
Political fallout
Pushkin expressed disappointment, stating the court avoided the merits of whether the Governor and Speaker violated the law. “From the beginning, Gov. Morrisey and Speaker Hanshaw used delay and procedural maneuvering to avoid accountability and run roughshod over the law simply because the law no longer benefited them,” he wrote, urging West Virginians to stay vigilant.
Republican Chris Claggett won the seat in the November 2025 general election, defeating Democrat David Michaels. Earlier this year, Claggett faced criticism for racist social‑media posts, prompting condemnation from Speaker Hanshaw and Republican Party Chair Josh Holstein.
Judicial composition
Justice Bill Flanigan, a former Republican lawmaker, recused himself from the decision. Senior Status Justice Beth Walker (sitting by special assignment) and Justice Charles Trump joined Chief Justice Bunn in a separate opinion, while Justice Bill Wooton also filed a concurring opinion.
The ruling underscores the importance of procedural standing in West Virginia’s courts and clarifies the limits of judicial intervention in legislative appointments.
Original reporting: WCHS Eyewitness News Charleston (local) — read the source article.