Three weeks before the May 19 Republican primary, former Washington County GOP chairman Dave Ball emailed County Commissioner Nick Sherman asking for an update on a criminal investigation he had requested into state Senate candidate Al Buchtan’s residency. Ball’s May 1 message cited the Pennsylvania election code and warned that “suspicious circumstances” required action by the elections board.
Background on the residency dispute
During an April 23 elections‑board meeting, Ball formally asked the board to investigate Buchtan’s claim that he lived in a Canonsburg apartment while his family resided in a home in Cumberland Township, Greene County. Earlier that month, a Commonwealth Court judge ruled that Buchtan’s true residence was the family home, removing him from Washington County’s voter rolls. The ruling allowed Buchtan to stay on the ballot for the 46th State Senate District, where he faced incumbent Republican Senator Camera Bartolotta.
Ball argued the court’s decision demonstrated voter fraud, noting that Buchtan had voted in Canonsburg in the November off‑year election.
Commissioner’s response and escalation
On May 7, Sherman replied that the elections board had forwarded Ball’s request to District Attorney Jason Walsh, who then sent it to the state Attorney General’s office for review. Sherman wrote, “At this time, it is now considered an active investigation with the AG’s office and we cannot make any further comment.”
During the same period, the Senate Republican Caucus Committee began sending mailers and text messages to voters stating that Buchtan was under an “active criminal investigation” for voter fraud, citing a Washington County election‑official email as the source. It remains unclear whether Sherman’s email or another communication sparked the caucus’s outreach.
Attorney General’s handling of the case
The Attorney General’s office did not inform District Attorney Walsh that it had accepted the case until May 15, just four days before the primary. After the election, the AG’s office notified Walsh on August 13 that it had “investigated this matter” and ultimately “declined to file or otherwise pursue any criminal charges” against Buchtan.
Legal fallout and political context
Ball denied forwarding Sherman’s email to the Senate Republican Caucus Committee or coordinating with political operatives in Harrisburg. “No, I didn’t. That was just information to me,” he told reporters, adding that he did not know who contacted the caucus.
Sherman said his role was limited to referring the matter to prosecutors, as required by Washington County policy. “A constituent of mine accused someone of criminal wrongdoing,” he said. “Per the policies and procedures of Washington County, any time someone calls my office about criminal wrongdoing, we turn it over to the district attorney’s office, because they are the ones that pursue criminal investigations. And that’s what I did.”
Both Sherman and fellow Republican Commissioner Electra Janis, who also supported Bartolotta, are being sued in federal court by Buchtan, who alleges the commissioners used their positions to tip the primary in Bartolotta’s favor. Bartolotta won the primary by a narrow 53.5‑to‑46.5 percent margin and was re‑elected to a fourth term on Nov. 3.
Open‑records request and next steps
The correspondence between Ball and Sherman was released on Monday after the Observer‑Reporter and Herald‑Standard filed an open‑records request on July 6. The county initially sought a 30‑day delay, prompting the state Office of Open Records to order Washington County officials on Oct. 30 to continue searching for any email referencing an “active investigation” into Buchtan, giving them a deadline of the following Monday.
The investigation’s outcome remains pending, and the case highlights ongoing concerns about candidate residency requirements and the proper handling of voter‑fraud allegations in Pennsylvania’s local elections.
Original reporting: Herald-Standard – latest news for Uniontown, Pennsylvania — read the source article.