A registered voter from Doral, Alejandro Peñuela, filed an emergency petition with the Florida Supreme Court on Tuesday, urging the justices to issue a writ of mandamus that would require Governor Ron DeSantis to schedule a special election for the vacant Senate District 39 seat.
Background and legal basis
The seat became vacant on August 25, 2026, when former Republican state Sen. Bryan Ávila resigned to join U.S. Rep. Byron Donalds’ gubernatorial ticket as his running mate. While DeSantis’ office promised in August that an election announcement was “coming soon,” no date has been set for either a special primary or a special general election.
Peñuela’s petition cites Florida Statutes Section 100.111(2), which states that when a legislative vacancy occurs, the governor “shall fix the dates of a special primary election and a special election” after consulting with the secretary of state. The petition argues that the word “shall” leaves no legal wiggle room for delay.
Potential impact on representation
District 39 encompasses roughly 500,000 residents. If the election is not called promptly, those voters could be without representation in Tallahassee during the upcoming interim committee weeks and the regular legislative session that begins on March 2, 2027. Peñuela’s attorneys warn that constituents would be denied a vote both for a new senator and on Senate committee matters.
Historical context
Between 1999 and 2020, Florida governors took an average of just 7.6 days to schedule a special election after a vacancy, acting in fewer than five days in more than two dozen cases. By contrast, the 84‑day delay in District 39 is the longest recorded for a comparable vacancy.
The petition also notes that this is the tenth instance since 2021 where voters or candidates have had to go to court to compel DeSantis to call a special election. Prior examples include a 30‑day wait after the 2021 death of U.S. Rep. Alcee Hastings, a more than 90‑day wait later that year after three state lawmakers resigned, and four separate legislative vacancies in 2025 that were only resolved after lawsuits.
Governor’s perspective
While the filing does not include a direct statement from the governor’s office, DeSantis has emphasized the importance of thorough preparation and ensuring that election logistics are properly coordinated with the secretary of state. Supporters argue that a careful approach helps maintain election integrity and provides ample time for candidates to campaign.
Legal request
Peñuela is asking the Florida Supreme Court to fast‑track the case and issue a writ of mandamus ordering the governor to set election dates without further delay. If granted, the court would compel the administration to place the special primary and general election on the calendar, restoring representation for District 39 residents before the legislative session begins.
Original reporting: Tampa Free Press — read the source article.