TOLEDO, Ohio – A local court has found that Al Alim Zakiel, 57, is currently not competent to stand trial for the deadly shooting that took place outside the St. Paul Community Center on Dec. 26, 2025. The ruling, issued on Nov. 3, 2026, comes after a thorough competency hearing and reflects the court’s commitment to ensuring a fair legal process.
Details of the incident
According to police reports, the incident occurred near the 200 block of 13th Street. Witnesses said a man appeared intoxicated and was standing outside the community center with a firearm. Andrew Shively, 36, approached the man in an attempt to enter the building. A heated exchange ensued, and Shively was shot. He was transported to a nearby hospital where he later died.
Charges and legal proceedings
Zakiel has been indicted on two counts of murder, a felonious assault charge, and a tampering‑with‑evidence charge. The indictment was filed on Feb. 4, 2026. After a multi‑agency effort that included the U.S. Marshals Service, authorities located and arrested Zakiel in Detroit in January 2026.
The court set Zakiel’s bond at $1.125 million, a figure that remains in effect while he undergoes treatment.
Competency hearing outcome
During the Nov. 3 hearing, Judge Ian English concluded that Zakiel is unlikely to be competent to stand trial at this time. However, the judge expressed confidence that with appropriate treatment, Zakiel is likely to become competent within one year. Accordingly, Judge English ordered that Zakiel receive treatment at Northwest Ohio Behavioral Healthcare.
What competency means
Competency to stand trial is a legal standard that requires a defendant to understand the nature of the charges against them and to be able to assist counsel in their defense. When a defendant is found incompetent, the court typically orders mental health treatment aimed at restoring competency, after which the case proceeds to trial.
Community response
The shooting has left the Toledo community mourning the loss of Shively, a resident known for his involvement in local events. Community leaders have called for continued vigilance and cooperation with law‑enforcement to keep public spaces safe.
Local officials emphasized that the court’s decision reflects a balance between public safety and the constitutional rights of the accused. By ensuring that Zakiel receives proper treatment before facing trial, the justice system upholds due process while addressing the community’s need for accountability.
Next steps
Zakiel will remain under the care of Northwest Ohio Behavioral Healthcare while his competency is evaluated. The court will schedule a follow‑up hearing to determine whether he has regained the ability to participate in his defense. If competency is restored, the case will move forward on the murder and related charges.
Residents are encouraged to stay informed through local news outlets and to report any suspicious activity to law‑enforcement. The Toledo Police Department continues to work with state and federal partners to maintain public safety in the area.
Original reporting: 13abc WTVG Toledo (news) — read the source article.
