THURMOND, W.Va. — In a move to protect its dwindling heritage, the town of Thurmond filed a lawsuit Wednesday seeking a federal injunction against the National Park Service (NPS). The suit asks a judge to halt demolition of twelve historic buildings that have stood as symbols of the former railroad community since the early 20th century.
Town claims NPS abandoned preservation promises
The complaint alleges that for more than three decades the NPS told Thurmond’s residents it would preserve, rehabilitate, and adaptively reuse the structures so the town could serve as a heritage‑tourism gateway to the New River Gorge National Park & Preserve. Instead, plaintiffs say the agency allowed the buildings to fall into disrepair, leaving the few remaining locals to maintain the grounds on their own.
According to the filing, the NPS acquired the properties from former owners under the understanding that they would be preserved as part of a historic museum. The town’s mayor is quoted in the lawsuit stating that residents were assured their homes would become part of a historical exhibit.
Legal deficiencies cited
The suit contends the NPS failed to provide a complete set of demolition plans, neglected the 30‑day review period required under a Programmatic Agreement, and did not finish consulting on mitigation measures before mobilizing demolition crews. The complaint also points to a 2005 NPS study that gave Thurmond its highest historical‑significance rating and recommended expanding the National Register district.
Thurmond, incorporated in 1903, once boasted a population of more than 400 during the 1930s railroad boom. The 2020 census recorded just five residents, and today most of the town’s structures sit vacant, with a few still occupied, including the depot that now functions as a visitor center for the national park.
Buildings slated for demolition
The lawsuit lists the twelve structures slated for demolition:
- Charles Ashley Outbuilding and Garage
- James Humphrey Sr. House
- McGuffin Garage
- May Bagoski House
- Phillip A. McClung/Meadows House
- Harold Smith House
- Prince Brothers General Store
- Sidney Allen Ward House
- Camp Brookside Pool Chemical Building
- Erskine Pugh Rental House
- Wedzel Young House
In addition to stopping demolition, the town seeks a court order requiring the NPS to complete the full review and consultation process and to reconsider alternatives such as leasing the properties.
Community response
Local residents and preservation advocates have voiced strong support for the lawsuit, emphasizing the cultural and educational value of maintaining Thurmond’s historic fabric. They argue that preserving these structures aligns with the original intent of the National Register designation and offers a tangible link to the region’s railroad heritage.
While the NPS has not yet issued a public response, the lawsuit underscores a broader tension between federal land‑management agencies and the small communities that exist within or adjacent to protected lands. The outcome of this case could set a precedent for how historic resources are treated in other National Park Service holdings across the country.
Original reporting: WCHS Eyewitness News Charleston (local) — read the source article.