Logan Square – After buying The Bagelers in Lincoln Park in 2022, attorney Sarah Flosi is bringing the beloved neighborhood bagel shop to 2415 N. Milwaukee Avenue. The new space, the former Blazed Bakery, will open in late December and become the only dedicated bagel shop in Logan Square.
Family‑owned vision drives the expansion
Flosi, who left a successful legal career to open a café, says the venture is “nothing fancy, just good food with real ingredients.” She and her brother‑in‑law, Tom Pradtl, who serves as general manager, are committed to keeping the concept family‑owned and locally focused. “Chicago needs family‑owned places and we have to keep that alive here,” Flosi explains.
Chicago‑style bagels, made the traditional way
The Logan Square shop will serve the same Chicago‑style bagels that made the original location popular – hand‑rolled, kettle‑boiled and baked to a softer, sweeter texture than a typical bagel. Flosi notes, “There are a bunch of different styles going on, even in Chicago, but kettle‑boil is our way.” The menu includes the jalapeño‑cheddar bagel, which won top honors at this year’s inaugural Bagel Fest in Wrigleyville, as well as new breakfast sandwiches featuring chorizo, pastrami, maple sausage and a three‑cheese peppercorn bagel.
House‑made spreads and upgraded syrups
All cream cheeses are made in‑house, with garlic‑chive, giardiniera and a new French onion flavor joining the lineup. Flosi’s team also refreshed their house‑made syrups, adding a richer maple pecan option. Coffee beans are sourced from Hexe Coffee Co. in Lincoln Park, maintaining a local supply chain.
Affordable, grab‑and‑go pricing
Bagels with cream cheese are priced at $3, and sandwich combos start at $8.85. “We try to price things where people can grab and go every day and not feel like they are breaking the bank,” Flosi says.
Cozy, work‑friendly atmosphere
The new shop retains the original’s corner‑store feel, with added wood accents and a deep‑green color scheme. Seating for 55 guests, including booths and tables, will accommodate both to‑go customers and those who want to work on laptops. “If you come into The Bagelers, it will look very family‑owned and I think that’s what makes people like it,” Flosi adds.
Hours and location
The Logan Square location will mirror the Lincoln Park hours: 7 a.m.‑3 p.m. Monday‑Friday and 8 a.m.‑3 p.m. Saturday‑Sunday.
Flosi hopes the expansion will give Chicagoans another locally owned breakfast option as out‑of‑state chains move into the city. “My goal is to stay family‑owned and‑run. I think people sense the difference when they feel the owner’s presence onsite,” she says.
Original reporting: Block Club Chicago — read the source article.