The Tax Foundation released its 2027 State Tax Competitiveness Index, a benchmark that rates each state’s tax code on how well it supports economic growth and fiscal stability. The latest rankings reveal a stark contrast between the Mountain West and the Pacific Northwest, with Wyoming taking the top spot and Washington slipping to 47th place.
Why Wyoming leads
Wyoming earned the highest score because it imposes neither a corporate nor an individual income tax. Its unemployment insurance tax rate and property‑tax burden fall in the lower half of all states, reinforcing a simple, pro‑growth tax environment. The study notes that a recent ballot measure, Proposition 1, which would have exempted half of a primary residence’s value from property taxes, failed to pass. Had it succeeded, future rankings could shift as states adjust income or sales taxes to replace lost revenue.
Wyoming’s property‑tax rank of 39th still signals room for improvement. The authors suggest levy limits and other spending restraints to protect taxpayers while preserving essential services.
Montana’s mixed results
Montana dropped from fifth to seventh in the latest survey. The state’s reliance on federal taxable income as the basis for its own income tax, combined with exemptions for tips and overtime, has narrowed the tax base. Additionally, Montana continues to operate a tiered property‑tax system that taxes residential, commercial, and agricultural parcels at different rates, adding complexity.
Nevertheless, the state has taken positive steps: lawmakers lowered the top income‑tax rate and eliminated the marriage penalty. Governor Greg Gianforte’s proposal for a single, flat income‑tax rate could further improve Montana’s standing in future rankings.
Idaho’s decline
Idaho fell four spots to 13th after adopting House Bill 559 in 2026, which aligned the state’s tax code with the federal One Big Beautiful Bill Act by exempting tips and overtime from state taxation. The policy is projected to forgo roughly $155 million in the current fiscal year without delivering a corresponding boost in economic growth.
Washington’s slide
Washington’s ranking dropped one spot to 47th, primarily because the legislature added digital advertising to the sales‑tax base, pushing the state to the bottom of the sales‑tax bracket. The state did improve its property‑ and wealth‑tax rankings by cutting the top estate‑tax rate from 35 percent to 20 percent.
In 2026, Washington also enacted a 9.9 percent tax on income above $1 million, slated to take effect in 2028. If the measure remains in place, it could further erode the state’s competitiveness in upcoming studies.
Washington has become Idaho’s top feeder state for new residents, overtaking California, according to recent U.S. Census data. The migration pattern underscores how taxpayers respond to tax policy with their feet.
Implications for policymakers
The study’s authors caution that a well‑structured tax code alone will not transform a region into a metropolis, nor will a poor tax structure doom a thriving city. However, tax policy plays a substantial role in a state’s economic success or failure.
With a new majority in both houses of Congress favoring higher federal spending, state leaders are urged to adopt simple, neutral, and pro‑growth tax structures to shield their economies from potential federal tax changes. The declines of Montana and Idaho illustrate the importance of continual attention to tax competitiveness as other states adjust their policies.
Policymakers throughout the Mountain West—and especially those in Washington—should study the Index to identify reforms that boost income and growth while avoiding measures that dampen competitiveness and drive residents away.
Original reporting: Clark County Today (Vancouver WA) — read the source article.