The first time I walked into Taft’s Brewporium, I looked up at the vaulted ceiling before I even thought about ordering a beer. That’s the thing about the place — it used to be St. Paul’s Evangelical Church, built in 1850, and even after a full gut renovation, the architecture still stops you cold. The nave is enormous. The original stonework is intact. The stained glass is there, slightly industrial now, filtered light landing across long communal tables while someone at the bar orders a second pint of Camptown Lager.
Taft’s sits on McMillan Street in East Walnut Hills, a neighborhood that’s been slowly exhaling after decades of disinvestment. The brewery opened in 2015 and was one of the earlier bets on the area’s return. That context matters when you’re sitting inside: a 160-year-old church that survived long enough to become something the neighborhood actually uses again.
I go for the beer first. The Forge line of IPAs is reliable — Psychographic, their hazy, is usually on tap and doesn’t beat you over the head with bitterness the way a lot of hazies do. The Maverick Chocolate Peanut Butter Stout sounds like a novelty but drinks like they actually tested it, not just named it. If you show up in fall, ask what’s rotating through the cask — they do interesting things with that program that don’t always make it onto the main menu board.
The food earns more respect than it probably gets credit for. It’s a brewpub menu done with actual attention: the smash burger is properly executed, with good caramelization on the patty and nothing unnecessary on top. The soft pretzels with beer cheese are exactly what you want after a bike ride or before a long evening. I’ve had the nachos here on a cold Tuesday and felt fully justified in my life choices. Prices are honest — most entrees land between twelve and seventeen dollars, pints around six or seven.
The building itself is split into distinct spaces. The main hall is cavernous and can feel loud on a busy Friday, but there’s a lower-level bar area that’s quieter, and in warmer months the outdoor patio wraps around part of the building in a way that lets you appreciate the stone exterior from outside. If you go on a weekend afternoon, families show up with kids in tow, and the place handles it without feeling like a family restaurant. That’s a harder balance than it looks.
One thing worth knowing: parking is street parking along McMillan, and it fills. If you’re coming from downtown or OTR, the drive is about ten minutes east and not dramatic, but plan for a couple of laps around the block. I’ve also walked over from the nearby Wasson Way trailhead, which is a solid plan if the weather cooperates.
What I keep coming back to isn’t any single beer or dish — it’s the room. There’s something genuinely strange and right about drinking a well-made lager under a vaulted stone ceiling on a Tuesday night in Cincinnati. The city has a lot of breweries now, more than it used to, and most of them are fine. Taft’s has the room nobody else has. That still counts for a lot.