Robert Devine, who retired from the Stoughton Police Department in 2022 as a deputy chief, is slated to receive an annual pension of $56,544. The figure comes from a filing with the Norfolk County Retirement System and reflects the benefits earned during his years of service.
Decertification does not bar pension under state law
Devine’s police certification was revoked last year by the Peace Officer Standards and Training (POST) Commission after an investigation linked him to the Sandra Birchmore case. The POST panel described his conduct as a “pattern of unprofessional police conduct that may escalate.” Despite the revocation, Massachusetts law states that a former officer who has not been criminally convicted remains eligible for retirement benefits.
Birchmore case background
Birchmore, then 23 and pregnant, was found dead in her Canton apartment in 2021. Although the death was initially ruled a suicide, federal investigators reopened the case after the Stoughton Police Department disclosed an internal review. Another former Stoughton officer, Matthew Farwell, was later convicted of murdering Birchmore and her unborn child, a federal offense protecting unborn children.
Devine was not charged in Birchmore’s death. During his POST hearing he asserted that Birchmore “lied about everything.” He is currently appealing the commission’s decision to decertify him.
Public reaction and legal context
The retirement payout has drawn criticism from some community members who argue that officers who lose their certification should not continue to collect public funds. Others point out that the law is clear: unless a former officer is convicted of a crime, the pension remains protected. The POST Commission’s findings and the ongoing appeal will likely shape future discussions about police accountability and retirement eligibility in Massachusetts.
What this means for Stoughton and the state
Stoughton city officials have not commented on the pension decision, but the case underscores the tension between ensuring public‑safety accountability and adhering to existing statutory provisions. Lawmakers and local leaders may consider legislative changes to address similar situations in the future, balancing the rights of retired officers with community expectations for accountability.
For now, Devine’s pension will be paid out annually, and the Birchmore case continues to unfold in federal court.
Original reporting: NBC10 Boston — read the source article.