A special investigation by the Indiana State Board of Accounts (SBOA) has uncovered serious oversight gaps at Indianapolis Public Schools’ Clarence Farrington School 61. The audit found that former administrative associate Tiffany Mercado received nine checks totaling $7,410 from the school’s extracurricular activity account between May 2024 and January 2025 for purchases that never materialized.
Details of the alleged theft
According to the SBOA report released on Nov. 5, Mercado submitted reimbursement claims for items that were never delivered, including $2,900 for playground sets, $1,182 for a staff‑appreciation lunch, $2,083 for headphones and organizers, $995 for staff T‑shirts, and $250 for a training session she could not confirm attending. The school’s principal, Mitchell Simmons, estimated the total loss at $9,799.
Marion County prosecutors have charged Mercado with a Level 6 felony for theft of property valued between $750 and $50,000. She resigned from the district in February 2025, roughly a month before Simmons reported the missing funds to police. Mercado later repaid $1,845, but a warrant remains outstanding after she failed to appear in court in August 2026.
Control deficiencies identified
The SBOA audit highlighted several policy violations that facilitated the fraud. District policy requires any purchase over $500 to be approved by the school board and reimbursed only after receipts are provided. These steps were not followed for the playground sets, and Mercado was allowed to sign checks—an action the report says should not have been permissible.
IPS policy also mandates that two authorized individuals sign each check, typically the principal and the treasurer for the extracurricular account. In this case, the school treasurer, a teacher, was on intermittent leave, and Mercado was granted check‑signing privileges. She approved at least one check written to herself—a $950 payment for a playground set that never arrived.
District response and next steps
In its response, the district attributed the loss to “one employee’s deliberate deception and from isolated building‑level departures from established district policy by another employee.” The district noted that Mercado fabricated price quotes and cancelled orders after receiving reimbursement.
When Simmons contacted the vendor for the staff T‑shirts, the vendor confirmed the order had been cancelled because no payment was received, corroborating the SBOA’s findings.
The State Board of Accounts is also seeking $5,529 from Mercado to cover the cost of the special investigation. It is unclear who will ultimately bear that expense, though the district had $100,000 in employee‑theft crime insurance during the relevant period. The SBOA chief of staff indicated the report has been referred to the Indiana attorney general’s office for further legal action.
Implications for IPS oversight
This case underscores the need for stricter adherence to IPS financial controls, especially regarding extracurricular funds. School administrators and board members are urged to reinforce policies that require dual signatures, board approval for larger purchases, and receipt verification before reimbursements are issued.
Community members and parents have expressed concern about how such lapses could affect school resources and student programs. The district has pledged to review its internal procedures and implement additional safeguards to prevent similar incidents.
IPS has not responded to further inquiries from local media about recovery of the remaining funds or any disciplinary action taken against other staff involved.
Original reporting: Mirror Indy — read the source article.