Rapid City, SD – As the U.S. Senate prepares to vote on the BAAJA Act, a sweeping federal reform of environmental review and permitting, South Dakota’s own leaders are divided. Governor Larry Rhoden publicly supports the legislation, arguing that modernizing the permitting process is essential for expanding energy projects that create jobs and strengthen the state’s economy.
Governor’s stance
In a Nov. 16 emailed statement to KOTA Territory News, Gov. Rhoden said, “This is a federal issue. Congress needs to deliver permitting reform, but I’m not going to endorse every provision in this legislation. I’m hopeful amendments can still improve the bill before final passage, but ultimately that is up to Congress.” He emphasized that a more efficient permitting system would remove unnecessary delays that currently hinder energy development, a sector that has long been a cornerstone of South Dakota’s prosperity.
Opposition from a bipartisan coalition
More than 40 state legislators, a handful of incoming lawmakers, over a dozen county committee chairs and Republican party leadership have signed a joint letter urging the state’s congressional delegation to vote against the act. Their concerns focus on potential losses to agricultural opportunities, infringements on private property rights, threats to tribal sovereignty, and broader economic impacts on rural communities.
“It really tramples on tribal sovereignty and protections that are necessary for our lands and waters across South Dakota,” said Democratic lawmaker Erik Muckey of Sioux Falls. He warned that the bill, as written, would prioritize corporate interests over local taxpayers and citizens.
Republican lawmaker backs the bill
Not all state officials share the coalition’s alarm. Republican House Representative Jim Mehlhaff of Pierre told KOTA the bill is necessary to spur energy development. He dismissed concerns that federal regulators could override state commissions on energy permits that exceed a one‑year deadline, a point previously raised by U.S. Sen. Mike Rounds when he voted against a motion to advance the bill on Nov. 9.
“Is it reasonable for the permitting process to take more than a year to get through the Public Utilities Commission?” Mehlhaff asked. “If there are hurdles in state law that people are basically using as tools to obstruct and slow down, maybe there is some justification for removing that process and taking it to a different level.”
Historical context of property‑rights protection
Muckey noted that passing the BAAJA Act could undermine Governor Rhoden’s past policy achievements, including his signing of a landmark 2025 property‑rights bill that protected South Dakota landowners from eminent‑domain seizures by carbon‑pipeline developers. That legislation was hailed by many as a defense of private property and local control.
“The question that comes from this act is, who benefits?” Muckey asked. “And the benefit is being clearly laid out for companies that want to pass through, streamline federal permitting processes so they don’t have to listen to the concerns of local taxpayers and local citizens. That’s really what this is about.”
National implications and local impact
The BAAJA Act, if passed, would shift many permitting decisions from state and local authorities to federal agencies, potentially reducing the ability of South Dakota’s farmers, ranchers and tribal nations to influence projects that affect their land and water. Supporters argue that a uniform federal framework could accelerate clean‑energy infrastructure, while opponents fear it could erode the state’s tradition of local control and stewardship.
Governor Rhoden recently joined 21 Republican governors from other states in urging Congress to pass the legislation, underscoring a broader regional push for streamlined permitting that they say will keep the United States competitive in the global energy market.
What’s next?
The Senate is slated to vote on the BAAJA Act in the coming weeks. South Dakota’s congressional delegation will face pressure from both the governor’s office and the bipartisan coalition of local leaders. Residents and stakeholders are encouraged to contact their representatives to voice support or concerns, especially as the debate touches on core issues of property rights, agricultural viability, tribal sovereignty and the state’s economic future.
Original reporting: KOTA (Gray) – local — read the source article.